Skip to main content

Kaer NewsWorld

Israeli forces detain 90 volunteers including candidate Lander at West Bank harvest

US congressional candidate Brad Lander was among 90 volunteers detained by Israeli forces on Wednesday while harvesting olives near Nehalim in the West Bank, with 33 US citizens held.

4 min read
Israeli forces detain 90 volunteers including candidate Lander at West Bank harvestPhoto: The Independent

Key points

Israeli forces detained 90 volunteers, including US congressional candidate Brad Lander, during an olive harvest near Nehalim in the West Bank on Wednesday.

Israeli forces detained 90 volunteers, including US congressional candidate Brad Lander, during an olive harvest near Nehalim in the occupied West Bank on Wednesday. The group was accompanying Palestinian farmers to groves as part of the olive harvest when troops arrived and declared the area a closed military zone. Lander is the Democratic nominee for New York's 10th congressional district in the November 3 midterm elections.

The detentions matter because Lander is a sitting candidate for the US House of Representatives, and because the incident highlights the contested access Palestinian farmers have to their own groves. Rabbis for Human Rights said Palestinian farmers in the area had been unable to access the groves for three years. The group's volunteers went to accompany them during the harvest, which drew a large military and police response.

What the group was doing there

Rabbis for Human Rights, an Israeli organisation, said its volunteers were working near Bethlehem, accompanying Palestinian farmers to groves as part of the olive harvest. The group's acting executive director, Anton Goodman, said the volunteers had come to accompany farmers to land they had been unable to access for three years. Israeli forces arrived around two hours after the harvest began and told the volunteers the area was a closed military zone, the organisation said.

Israeli forces arrived two hours after the volunteers had begun working and declared the field a closed military zone, according to the Jerusalem Post. Activists told the Post that they complied with the military orders and agreed to leave the area, but were still detained. Rabbi Jill Jacobs, chief executive of American rights organisation T'ruah, said the group volunteered to leave but was instead put on buses by Israeli forces and taken to a police station.

Activists were split between foreign nationals and Israeli citizens and transported to a police station for processing, the Jerusalem Post reported. Police took the foreign volunteers to the Etzion Regional Brigade headquarters for questioning, a source at the scene told the Post. One detained activist confirmed that no one was harmed during the process. Rabbi Jill Jacobs said some of those detained were taken inside the police station while others were held on a bus outside.

How the detentions unfolded

Among those detained were 33 US citizens, Jacobs said, along with a number of British and Canadian citizens. Lander was released with a warning, a source told the Jerusalem Post. Authorities are inclined to deport the foreign activists, the source added. As far as Jacobs knew, police had not made any formal accusations against the group, and it was not clear why they were detained or if they would be charged.

Rabbis for Human Rights said its work in the West Bank was peaceful and that it was the organisation's policy to comply with Israel Defense Forces orders. Jacobs criticised the military, saying it removed those who came to provide a protective presence rather than protecting Palestinian farmers. The Reform Movement in Israel and the Council of Reform Rabbis in Israel called the incident appalling, with Executive Director Anna Kislanski saying security forces were arresting rabbi activists instead of Jewish extremists.

Reactions from Jewish organisations

Lander wrote on X that he had been detained with a group of rabbis and volunteers. He said the group was simply harvesting olives in a grove near Nehalim in the West Bank, and that harvesting olives is not a crime under any law he knows. Former deputy attorney-general Yehoshua Schoffman, also detained, posted that there was no confrontation with soldiers or settler extremists in the area.

There was no immediate comment from Israeli police, the military or the US Embassy in Jerusalem. Lander, a Jewish American and former New York City comptroller, has criticised Israel's war in Gaza and is an ally of New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani. On Tuesday, Lander posted a video announcing he was volunteering in the West Bank with the Protect the Harvest coalition.

Frequently asked questions

Who was detained during the West Bank olive harvest?

Israeli forces detained 90 volunteers with Rabbis for Human Rights on Wednesday, including US congressional candidate Brad Lander and former deputy attorney-general Yehoshua Schoffman. Among those detained were 33 US citizens, plus British and Canadian citizens.

Why were the volunteers in the West Bank?

The volunteers with Rabbis for Human Rights were accompanying Palestinian farmers to groves near Bethlehem as part of the olive harvest. The group said Palestinian farmers in the area had been unable to access the groves for three years.

Was Brad Lander charged?

Lander was released with a warning, a source told the Jerusalem Post. Rabbi Jill Jacobs said police had not made formal accusations against the group, and it was not clear why they were detained or if they would be charged.

More from this edition