Skip to main content

Kaer NewsSoftware

Citizen Lab finds spyware spread through ads on 120,000 sites

Citizen Lab and Confiant reported on 15 October that Israeli firm Discover-Tech turned online ads into a zero-click spyware delivery system, compromising 45 Al Jazeera Windows devices in 2024 and 2025.

3 min read
Citizen Lab finds spyware spread through ads on 120,000 sitesPhoto: TechCrunch

Key points

Citizen Lab and Confiant found Israeli firm Discover-Tech used online ads to deliver zero-click spyware, compromising 45 Al Jazeera devices.

Citizen Lab and Confiant Threat Intelligence reported on 15 October that Israeli advertising firm Discover-Tech turned online ad networks into a zero-click spyware delivery system, compromising at least 45 Windows computers at media organisation Al Jazeera between 2024 and 2025. The University of Toronto lab called the technique AdFection and said it was the first confirmation of government-backed zero-click spyware delivered through online ads.

The findings matter because online ads load automatically on websites and apps, meaning a device can be infected without the victim clicking a link or opening a file. Ad networks are built to target specific people, devices, and organisations, so the same machinery that serves commercial adverts can be pointed at a single individual. Citizen Lab said this escalation puts a vast number of devices worldwide at risk.

How the ad system was abused

Discover-Tech's platform, called Controlium, plugs into real-time bidding — the automated auction system that decides which ad a user sees in the milliseconds a page loads. Rather than persuading a victim to click, attackers use the auction to profile and de-anonymise users, then push malicious code buried in an innocent-looking advert. Ads only needed to load on a page for the spying to occur.

Citizen Lab said at least two spyware makers, Candiru and Bindecy, used Discover-Tech's platform to target people. Candiru's spyware compromised the 45 Al Jazeera devices, confirmed because the broadcaster shared its network logs with researchers. Discover-Tech's site exposed source code on its login pages and publicly accessible user login records, letting researchers rebuild its control panel without a password.

Researchers found billions of exposed ad bidding records showing Discover-Tech's ads appeared across tens of thousands of mobile apps and websites between March and June 2026. An analysis of four billion advertising records found the ads reached nearly 200,000 websites and mobile apps in dozens of countries over four months. Discover-Tech's ads reached more than 120,000 websites and 75,000 apps.

What the exposed records revealed

The bidding records showed ads displayed on devices used by militaries, governments, critical infrastructure, and national cyber agencies, though it is unclear whether those displays caused infections. Confiant found potentially malicious ads on networks of the International Atomic Energy Agency and the International Criminal Court. Sites of NATO, the United Nations, the European Parliament, European Commission, and Council of the EU also featured the ads.

Confiant cofounder Jerome Dangu said Discover-Tech pumped out at least 10 million ads per day and that cookie matching let it track people beyond its own ad reach. He estimated hundreds of millions of people would have been touched, and said regions including Gaza and the West Bank were saturated. Confiant noted ads tied to Candiru were a tiny fraction of overall volume.

Citizen Lab senior researcher Bill Marczak said the findings were "surely just the tip of the iceberg" and urged people who might be targeted to disable ad tracking or block ads altogether. Wolfie Cristl, another Citizen Lab senior researcher, called online advertising "a systemic security threat." German European Parliament lawmaker Hannah Neumann said the possibility EU institutions were exposed should set off alarm bells.

Companies move against Discover-Tech

Google blocked Discover-Tech from its ad platforms "for systematically violating our policies" following a joint investigation with Citizen Lab and Confiant. IAB Europe suspended Discover-Tech from its list of globally approved vendors after an audit identified policy violations, and Comcast's Beeswax subsidiary removed the firm. Discover-Tech did not respond to requests for comment, nor did Al Jazeera.

Citizen Lab said it was not clear which governments were behind the attacks. Candiru was blacklisted by the US Commerce Department in 2021 for allegedly supplying spyware used against government officials, journalists, activists, and academics, and was acquired by Integrity Labs in 2025. Discover-Tech was founded in 2020, and its chief executive Dekel Boni did not respond to messages.

Frequently asked questions

What did Citizen Lab discover about online ads and spyware?

Citizen Lab and Confiant reported that Israeli firm Discover-Tech used its Controlium advertising platform to deliver zero-click spyware through online ads. The technique, named AdFection, infected devices without any user interaction, and compromised at least 45 Windows computers at Al Jazeera.

How many websites and devices were affected?

Discover-Tech's ads appeared on more than 120,000 websites and 75,000 apps, with an analysis of four billion records showing nearly 200,000 sites reached over four months. Confiant estimated at least 10 million ads per day, touching hundreds of millions of people.

Which companies responded to the Discover-Tech findings?

Google blocked Discover-Tech from its ad platforms for systematically violating policies. IAB Europe suspended the firm from its approved vendor list after an audit, and Comcast's Beeswax subsidiary removed it. Discover-Tech did not respond to requests for comment.

More from this edition