Skip to main content

Kaer NewsSoftware

EU proposes Digital Fairness Act banning dark patterns and loot boxes

The European Commission proposed the Digital Fairness Act on 11 November, banning dark patterns and loot boxes for minors, with fines up to 6 percent of global revenue.

5 min read
EU proposes Digital Fairness Act banning dark patterns and loot boxesPhoto: Engadget

Key points

The EU proposed the Digital Fairness Act to ban dark patterns and loot boxes for minors, with fines up to 6% of global revenue.

The European Commission proposed the Digital Fairness Act on 11 November, a package of consumer protection rules that would ban dark patterns, restrict loot boxes for minors, and force clearer pricing online. The act, unveiled by the EU Commission, targets practices that harm children and push people into spending more, including unclear pricing, addictive design features, and ads aimed at minors. Companies in breach could face fines up to six percent of their global revenue, according to the draft copy.

The package represents the most significant reform of EU consumer protection rules in more than 20 years, said Michael McGrath, the EC Consumer Protection Commissioner. Existing consumer rules were developed before ecommerce, the attention economy, and use of personal data for marketing took off, he said at a press conference. "The digital fairness act will make sure the digital economy works for consumers and not against them," McGrath said. The act also aims to give consumers annual savings of up to 13.7 billion euros, according to official figures.

What the act bans

The act would ban dark patterns, which are practices that manipulate consumers into making decisions they would not otherwise make, such as falsely claiming a product is running low. It would also curb dynamic pricing by ticket retailers like Ticketmaster, force influencers to disclose when they are being paid to promote a product, and outrule personalized advertising and pricing targeting minors or taking advantage of sensitive data. Digital subscriptions would become easier to cancel, and consumers would gain a right to interact with human customer service.

For the video-game industry, the act introduces the first-ever sector-specific limits. Video games would no longer be able to earn money by offering minors micro-transactions to advance in the game, known as pay-to-win or pay-to-progress. There are also restrictions on loot boxes, which contain surprise virtual items that players can buy with real money. The law stipulates that in-app virtual currencies must be turned off by default for under-18s, and payment functions for children would require explicit parental approval.

The act also targets addictive design features on digital services, such as autoplay of videos and streaks, including on apps like Strava and Duolingo. Consumers would be able to turn off these features. The Commission says these practices encourage overspending, which is especially dangerous for vulnerable consumers like kids. Some of these patterns the EU has already restricted for children through its Kids Act, which in addition to banning under-13s from accessing social media and chatbots, targets addictive designs in those services.

Enforcement and fines

The proposal also shifts enforcement power from member states to a more centralized system. The Commission would gain direct powers to investigate large-scale cases with a major impact on consumers, speed up coordination with member states, and strengthen enforcement against non-EU companies. Non-EU companies would be required to appoint a local legal representative to cooperate with authorities. The Commission could fine firms up to 6 percent of their worldwide annual turnover in cases that affect more than two-thirds of the EU population.

The act is designed to fill gaps between existing regulations, including the Digital Services Act, the Digital Markets Act, and August's AI Act, said executive vice president Henna Virkkunen. "Not duplicate this," she said. The package should simplify consumer protection rules across the bloc's 27 members and be a "strong safety net in the digital world," she added. The Commission also proposed a revised Consumer Protection Cooperation regulation with sharper enforcement tools.

Consumer protection groups like the BEUC welcomed the proposals as a necessary step to regain digital control. However, business associations like Bitkom expressed skepticism about potential additional bureaucratic burdens for law-abiding companies. The gaming industry was more critical. In a joint statement, the European Game Developer Federation and Video Games Europe, which includes Sony and Epic Games, said the proposed definition of pay-to-win is "fundamentally flawed, lacks clear definitions and would create huge confusion for players and developers alike" since it could cover "any purchase."

Industry reaction

The gaming groups argue that the industry already does a good job regulating itself with parental controls and the content rating system PEGI, which the DFA doesn't take into account. "Effectively, the DFA moves all decisions from parents and children to the Commission," they wrote. The industry says the rules would "cripple the competitiveness of Europe's world-leading video games industry." Video game spending in the bloc topped 27 billion euros, accounting for 17% of the global market, last year, according to the European Audiovisual Observatory.

The proposal now goes to the EU Parliament and Council for negotiation. The Commission aims to accelerate cross-border cooperation through strengthened enforcement rules. The act would also take on unfair personalized ads and prices that target minors, while putting an end to subscription traps that are difficult to cancel. The Commission's proposal is part of a broader effort to adapt EU consumer law to the realities of the modern data and attention economy, as the bloc seeks to protect consumers in an increasingly digital marketplace.

The Digital Fairness Act is one of several recent EU regulatory moves. On Friday, the European Commission said ByteDance's TikTok had breached Digital Services Act rules with the "rabbit hole effect" of its "For You" feed algorithm. In July, it found Meta to be in breach of the act due to similar features on Instagram and Facebook. If confirmed, both companies may now face fines of up to 6 percent of worldwide annual turnover. The new regulation aims to fill gaps between these existing rules, not duplicate them.

The Commission's proposal is now subject to negotiations with the European Parliament and the Council, with the final shape of the act still to be determined. The act is expected to be a key piece of the EU's digital strategy, alongside the AI Act and the Digital Services Act. The Commission's goal is to ensure that businesses compete on the merits of their products and services, not on their ability to exploit consumers, as McGrath said. The next step is the legislative process, with no date yet set for adoption.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Digital Fairness Act?

The Digital Fairness Act is a proposed EU regulation to ban dark patterns, addictive design, and loot boxes for minors, and to improve consumer protection online. It was proposed by the European Commission on 11 November.

What penalties does the Digital Fairness Act impose?

Companies in breach could face fines up to 6 percent of their global revenue, according to the draft copy. The Commission would have direct powers to investigate large-scale cases affecting more than two-thirds of the EU population.

Why are gaming companies opposed to the Digital Fairness Act?

Gaming companies say the definition of pay-to-win is 'fundamentally flawed' and could cover 'any purchase,' creating confusion. They argue the industry already self-regulates with parental controls and PEGI ratings, and that the act would 'cripple' the industry.

More from this edition