Google, Meta and TikTok sue California over kids' social media law
Google, Meta and TikTok filed separate lawsuits on Wednesday against California's Assembly Bill 1709, which bans personalized feeds and autoplay for under-16s.
Photo: heise onlineKey points
Google, Meta and TikTok sued California to block a law banning addictive features for minors, arguing it violates free speech.
Google, Meta and TikTok filed separate lawsuits on Wednesday in California to block Assembly Bill 1709, a state law that bans social media platforms from offering minors under 16 features that could lead to compulsive use, such as personalized recommendations and autoplay videos. The companies filed in federal courts in San Jose, San Francisco and Los Angeles, respectively.
The law, signed by Governor Gavin Newsom on 10 September, is part of a larger package aimed at protecting children online. It prohibits platforms from providing 'psychologically exploitative features' to underage users and requires the deletion of children's accounts with those features. The law takes effect on 1 January 2027, unless a judge voids it or puts it on hold.
What the law bans
In their complaints, the companies argue the law violates the First Amendment's free speech protections and Section 230 of the federal Communications Decency Act, which broadly shields online platforms from liability over user content. Meta's lawsuit states: 'The state cannot, consistent with the First Amendment, override Meta's editorial judgments.' Google and TikTok made similar arguments.
The companies say the law wrongly compels them to present content to children in a way preferred by the state, substituting the state's judgment for that of parents. 'Parents are best positioned to make the right decisions for their families,' said Jose Castaneda, a Google spokesperson. 'Overly broad laws like this actually break the systems we've built to help kids find high-quality, age-appropriate videos.'
Legal arguments
TikTok argued that protected speech 'cannot be suppressed solely to protect the young from ideas or images that a legislative body thinks unsuitable.' The companies also contend the law forces them to honor California's preferred means of presenting content, which they say is an unconstitutional intrusion. The office of Rob Bonta, the California attorney general, who is the only defendant, said on Thursday it was reviewing the lawsuits. 'Our office is committed to defending California's commonsense laws to protect kids online,' it added. Newsom said when he signed the law that children's safety should always come first and that California 'will not stand by while unregulated technology puts our children at risk.'
Some organizations support the companies' position. The Electronic Frontier Foundation, a non-profit digital rights advocacy group, called the law 'a massive privacy and free speech nightmare' and unsuccessfully urged Newsom to veto the policy. The group argues the law could lead to invasive age verification and restrict access to information.
The lawsuits come amid broader scrutiny of social media's impact on children. Meta recently agreed to pay up to $18bn to settle a case with nearly all US states over children's privacy and social media addiction, and to limit teenagers' use of Facebook and Instagram. The company still denies any wrongdoing.
Broader context
Google, Meta and TikTok, along with Snapchat parent Snap, still face thousands of lawsuits by individuals, school districts, municipalities and other government entities claiming they sought to addict children and caused a mental health crisis. Many US states regulate children's access to social media, and countries worldwide have similar restrictions, including a ban in Australia on social media for children under 16.
The lawsuits are in their early stages, and the companies are seeking to block enforcement of the law before it takes effect on 1 January 2027. The California attorney general's office is reviewing the complaints, and the next step will be the court's response to the companies' requests for injunctions.
Frequently asked questions
What does California's Assembly Bill 1709 do?
The law bans social media platforms from offering minors under 16 personalized recommendations, autoplay videos, and other features that could lead to compulsive use. It takes effect on 1 January 2027.
Why are Google, Meta and TikTok suing California?
The companies argue the law violates the First Amendment's free speech protections and Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, and that it substitutes the state's judgment for that of parents.
What happens next in the lawsuit?
The California attorney general's office is reviewing the lawsuits. The companies are seeking to block enforcement of the law before it takes effect on 1 January 2027.


