Judge orders OpenAI to hand over hiring records in Apple case
On 13 October 2026, Judge Edward Davila ordered OpenAI to produce interview materials, forensic images and LINE messages within 14 days in Apple's trade secrets lawsuit.
Photo: 9to5MacKey points
A federal judge on 13 October 2026 ordered OpenAI to hand over hiring records, forensic images and private messages to Apple within 14 days.
Judge Edward Davila of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California on 13 October 2026 ordered OpenAI and related defendants to hand over hiring records, forensic images and private messages to Apple in its trade secrets lawsuit. The order grants in part Apple's motion for expedited discovery, filed on 4 August 2026, and sets production deadlines of 5 days for already-collected materials and 14 days for other requested documents.
The ruling matters because it gives Apple early access to evidence it says bears directly on its pending preliminary injunction motion, filed on 3 August 2026. Apple alleges former employees Chang Liu and Tang Yew Tan misused confidential Apple information to advance OpenAI's consumer hardware development. Expedited discovery lets Apple test those claims before the standard discovery process, which OpenAI had argued should simply proceed on its normal schedule.
What the order requires
The court ordered production of three categories of evidence. First, all forensic images the defendants have collected related to Apple's claims, including images identified in exhibits to the 31 August 2026 and 11 September 2026 declarations of Andrew Crain. Second, all documents used to guide or conduct interviews of Apple candidates for OpenAI's Consumer Hardware Products Group, including checklists, guides, instructions, manuals, scripts, and technical presentations summarising those interviews.
Third, Liu must produce all LINE messaging app conversations between him and Yu-Ting "Alyssa" Peng since 1 January 2026, including conversations containing messages cited in Liu's 31 August 2026 declaration. Apple also received approval to depose Liu, Tan and Peng within 30 days after receiving all responses to the permitted requests, plus a corporate-designee deposition of OpenAI Foundation, OpenAI Group PBC and io Products LLC.
Judge Davila denied Apple's request to expedite access to OpenAI research and development documents on metal finishes, power management and battery functionality for consumer hardware products, finding those better suited to ordinary merits discovery. He also denied, for now, Apple's request to depose a fourth individual listed in its narrowed requests. Apple had argued these materials were needed quickly to support its injunction motion.
What the judge denied
The judge deferred ruling on all requests and deposition topics using the term "Apple Originated Information," which he called amorphous as currently defined. Apple has five days to confer with the defendants and submit a more tailored definition for the court to evaluate. Davila also declined to hold that the permitted depositions come in addition to the deposition limits in the federal rules.
Apple filed its complaint on 10 July 2026, alleging trade secret misappropriation under the Defend Trade Secrets Act and breach of the individual defendants' Intellectual Property Agreements. The case was reassigned to Judge Davila on 23 July 2026. Apple alleges an investigation uncovered a pattern of trade secret theft by former employees now at OpenAI, including using Apple's proprietary information to aid OpenAI's hardware development.
The allegations behind the case
Apple further alleges former employees coached others considering leaving Apple for OpenAI on what information to bring to interviews, and instructed new hires on avoiding scrutiny when they left. Apple also accuses the corporate defendants of acting in concert as an enterprise exploiting its confidential information to help OpenAI enter the consumer hardware market. OpenAI opposed the discovery motion on 18 August 2026, arguing Apple's demands were overly broad.
The court applied the Ninth Circuit's good-cause standard, weighing whether a preliminary injunction is pending, the request breadth, purpose, compliance burden, and how far ahead of typical discovery the request came. The court agreed that because forensic images of Liu's devices had become prominent in the injunction motion, some requested discovery bore a clear relationship to that motion. It rejected the defendants' argument that Apple's delay alone justified denial.
What happens next
Apple sought expedited discovery on 4 August 2026, after moving for a preliminary injunction on 3 August 2026. Apple replied on 25 August and filed a supplemental brief on 31 August presenting its forensic expert's review of Liu's MacBook. The defendants responded on 11 September with their own expert's findings. After a 14 September status conference, the parties filed a joint submission with Apple's narrowed requests on 18 September 2026.
Judge Davila found the motion suitable for disposition without oral argument under the district's local rules and vacated the hearing scheduled for 14 October 2026. The permitted depositions of Liu, Tan and Peng must occur within 30 days after Apple receives all responses to the permitted requests, as must the corporate-designee deposition covering the positions, roles and responsibilities of the designated witnesses.
Frequently asked questions
What did the judge order OpenAI to hand over?
Judge Edward Davila ordered production of forensic images collected in connection with Apple's claims, documents used to guide or conduct interviews of Apple candidates for OpenAI's Consumer Hardware Products Group, and all LINE messages between Chang Liu and Alyssa Peng since 1 January 2026.
How long does OpenAI have to comply?
The court gave OpenAI 5 days to turn over materials already collected in the litigation and 14 days for any other materials related to the requests.
When was Apple's trade secrets lawsuit filed?
Apple filed its complaint on 10 July 2026, alleging trade secret misappropriation under the Defend Trade Secrets Act. The case was reassigned to Judge Edward Davila on 23 July 2026.


