Skip to main content

Kaer NewsPolitics

Lula and Bolsonaro trade insults in Brazil's fiery run-off debate

Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva and senator Flavio Bolsonaro called each other liars and traded corruption accusations in Sao Paulo on 18 October, a week before the 25 October run-off.

3 min read
Lula and Bolsonaro trade insults in Brazil's fiery run-off debatePhoto: Al Jazeera

Key points

Lula and Bolsonaro traded personal attacks and corruption accusations in their first presidential run-off debate on 18 October, a week before the 25 October vote.

Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva and right-wing senator Flavio Bolsonaro traded personal attacks in their first presidential run-off debate in Sao Paulo on 18 October, a week before the 25 October vote. The two men called each other liars multiple times, accused each other of corruption, and clashed over public security, healthcare, the economy, and Brazil's ties to the United States.

The debate matters because it is the first time the two candidates have faced each other directly, after both declined earlier opportunities. Polls show a tight race: two polls this week put Bolsonaro at 51% of voting intentions against Lula's 49%, narrowing an edge he had held since the first round, where he finished with 47% to Lula's 45% on 4 October.

What the debate changed

Lula, who is 80 and seeking a fourth term, called Bolsonaro 'a habitual liar, a thug' and physically distanced himself on stage from the candidate he called a 'militiaman', alluding to alleged ties to Rio de Janeiro's paramilitary groups. Bolsonaro, 45, paced behind Lula throughout the debate, shaking his head and smirking as his rival spoke.

Bolsonaro retorted that it was better to keep Lula at a distance 'because my wallet could be stolen', and said 'Brazil is going to retire you'. Lula repeatedly asked viewers to 'look it up on Google' to prove his adversary was lying, and demanded an explanation about a corruption investigation involving Bolsonaro's father, a question his opponent dodged by calling Lula a 'clown'.

The two men clashed over spending policy. Bolsonaro accused Lula of 'reckless spending to get re-elected', pointing to social measures announced during the campaign. Bolsonaro dodged the question throughout the debate.

Where the numbers came from

On healthcare, Bolsonaro admitted his father's handling of the COVID-19 pandemic 'wasn't an area where we saw the best results during Bolsonaro's presidency. I'll offer a mea culpa here.' Lula portrayed his opponent as out of touch with poor Brazilians, saying: 'My opponent only knows about buses from books. He has never even stepped foot on one.'

Bolsonaro also raised a potential corruption case involving one of Lula's sons, while Lula questioned Bolsonaro's ties to US President Donald Trump and plans to 'hand over' Brazil's rare earth minerals, saying: 'It is striking how the Bolsonaro family is subservient to American interests.' Lula said he wanted the votes of prisoners, including Jair Bolsonaro, telling him: 'Vote for me, Bolsonaro, you know your son, you know I'm better than him.'

Jair Bolsonaro is serving a 27-year sentence under house arrest for a botched coup bid after his failed 2022 re-election. Also on 18 October, Brazil's federal police asked the Supreme Court to open an investigation into Flavio Bolsonaro over a money laundering accusation involving a lawyer close to him. The candidate is already under investigation for links to Daniel Vorcaro, a disgraced former banker.

What happens before the vote

Tens of thousands of supporters rallied before the debate. Monitors at the University of Sao Paulo counted about 71,000 people at a Bolsonaro rally on Paulista Avenue and about 56,000 at a Lula rally led by singer Caetano Veloso on Copacabana Beach in Rio de Janeiro. Lula spent 580 days in prison in 2018 and 2019 on a corruption conviction later annulled over flaws in the investigation. Both candidates are trying to reach the 33 million voters who stayed home in the first round, equal to about one in five eligible voters. A second debate is scheduled for 23 October, two days before the run-off vote on 25 October.

Frequently asked questions

When did Lula and Bolsonaro hold their first run-off debate?

They held their first presidential run-off debate on 18 October in Sao Paulo, a week before the 25 October vote. Both candidates had declined earlier opportunities to debate.

Who is leading in the polls before the run-off?

Two polls showed Flavio Bolsonaro at 51% of voting intentions against Lula's 49%, narrowing an edge he had held since the first round, where he led with 47% to Lula's 45% on 4 October.

What insults were traded in the debate?

Lula called Bolsonaro 'a habitual liar, a thug' and a 'militiaman'. Bolsonaro called Lula a 'clown' and said it was better to keep him at a distance 'because my wallet could be stolen.'

More from this edition