Skip to main content

Kaer NewsSoftware

Meta ordered to pay $25 billion in New Mexico privacy case

A New Mexico judge ordered Meta to pay $25 billion on 21 October after a jury found more than 43 million violations of the state's consumer protection law.

4 min read
Meta ordered to pay $25 billion in New Mexico privacy casePhoto: The Verge

Key points

A New Mexico judge ordered Meta to pay $25 billion after a jury found more than 43 million violations of the state's consumer protection law.

A New Mexico state District Judge, Francis Mathew, ordered Meta to pay $25 billion in penalties on 21 October after a jury found the company misled Facebook users about privacy and content moderation. The jury counted more than 43 million violations of New Mexico's consumer protection laws, each carrying a penalty of up to $5,000.

The ruling is the biggest legal hit Meta has taken this year, and one of the largest financial penalties against a corporation in US history, according to the New Mexico Attorney General's office. It follows a two-week trial in Santa Fe and a jury verdict delivered in September.

How the penalty was calculated

The arithmetic behind the award starts with the violation count. At $5,000 per violation, the maximum penalty came to about $219 billion. The state asked for $35 billion to $40 billion. Meta requested no more than $3.45 billion. Judge Mathew settled on $25 billion. Judge Mathew wrote that the extraordinary number of willful violations found by the jury, the duration and repetition of the conduct, the breadth of subjects on which violations occurred and the involvement of senior Facebook leadership justified the highest penalty allowed under the law. He described Facebook's promised post-scandal investigation as willfully ineffective.

The case was filed in 2021 and was not directly about the data Cambridge Analytica harvested. It targeted Facebook's statements over the years about user data, privacy settings and content moderation. Jurors found that 26 of 29 statements made by Meta and its leadership on privacy and content moderation were misleading.

What Meta and the state argued

Meta's chief legal officer, C.J. Mahoney, said the ruling and the Attorney General's approach make it all but impossible to do business in New Mexico. He said the lawsuit seeks to impose a tax on speech to enforce new rules for what people can say online, and that Meta is confident it will prevail on appeal.

Meta lawyer Matt Nicholson argued in court that a sum as high as $40 billion would be shocking to the conscience, and said the jury did not find that any New Mexican heard or saw the statements or was harmed by them. New Mexico attorney Randi McGinn urged the court to stand up to tech titans who think they are bulletproof.

New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez said the case has always been about more than one company or one scandal. He said it is about whether corporations can mislead consumers about what happens to their personal information without facing meaningful consequences. He told reporters the money would go into a fund for the state's education system.

Where the money goes

The penalty will be paid into New Mexico's school system, with interest accruing at 15 percent a year until it is paid in full. Torrez said at a press conference that the state may have paid for the construction of schools for the next 100 years. The award dwarfs other recent rulings and settlements involving Meta. In another New Mexico state court ruling, the company was ordered to pay nearly $1 billion in civil penalties and abatement over the safety of its products. In a separate agreement with most other state attorneys general, Meta settled kids online safety complaints for $17.1 billion, of which $5.3 billion is contingent on YouTube and TikTok installing similar measures.

New Mexico skipped that multistate settlement, which included nearly $459 million specifically for Cambridge Analytica data harvesting claims, and that opened the door to this trial. The amount awarded far exceeds the $5 billion fine the Federal Trade Commission levied against Facebook in 2019. Meta plans to appeal the verdict, which could reduce the final payment. The ruling is the second legal defeat for Meta in New Mexico in six months: in March, a jury found the company misled users about the safety of young people on Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp and ordered it to pay $375 million in civil penalties, followed by an additional $567 million payment into a state fund for teen mental health.

Frequently asked questions

How much was Meta ordered to pay in the New Mexico privacy case?

Judge Francis Mathew ordered Meta to pay $25 billion in penalties on 21 October. The jury found more than 43 million violations of New Mexico's consumer protection laws, each carrying a penalty of up to $5,000, which produced a maximum of about $219 billion before the judge reduced it.

Why was Meta ordered to pay the penalty?

A Santa Fe jury found that Meta misled Facebook users in New Mexico about who could access their personal information and how harmful content was handled on its platforms. Jurors found 26 of 29 statements made by Meta and its leadership on privacy and content moderation were misleading.

What happens to the $25 billion?

New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez said all the money awarded would go into a fund for the state's education system. Interest accrues at 15 percent a year until the penalty is paid in full. Meta has said it will appeal the verdict, which could reduce the final payment.

More from this edition