Skip to main content

Kaer NewsSoftware

Elvis and Eminem rights holders sue Suno over AI cloning

Rights holders for Elvis Presley and Eminem filed separate federal lawsuits on 6 November accusing Suno of copying 859 and 269 works respectively.

5 min read
Elvis and Eminem rights holders sue Suno over AI cloningPhoto: Engadget

Key points

Elvis and Eminem rights holders sued Suno on 6 November, alleging unauthorized copying of 859 and 269 works respectively.

Elvis Presley's music rights holders and the publisher controlling much of Eminem's catalogue filed separate federal lawsuits against AI music generator Suno on 6 November, accusing the company of unlawfully using copyrighted music and artists' identities to generate new material. The Presley lawsuit, filed in the Northern District of California, was brought by a group including Authentic Brands Group, Raleigh Music Publishing, and other rights holders. The 51-page complaint alleges that Suno copied 859 Presley compositions to train its AI system and allowed users to generate music that imitates the singer's voice and likeness.

In a separate case filed the same day, Eight Mile Style, which controls or administers hundreds of Eminem compositions, accused Suno of infringing 269 works. The publisher alleges that the company copied its material to train its AI model and allows users to generate songs and lyrics resembling Eminem's work. Eminem himself is not a plaintiff in the case. Both lawsuits offered examples of songs created through the AI music generator that allegedly sound like Presley or mimic Eminem's lyrics.

The two complaints

The Presley lawsuit invokes Tennessee's Ensuring Likeness Voice and Image Security (ELVIS) Act, a 2024 law that makes it illegal for an AI company to clone a singer's voice. The plaintiffs argue that Suno enables users to reproduce characteristics of Presley's 'rich vocal timbre' without permission. The complaint names songs including 'All Shook Up,' 'Don't Be Cruel' and 'Can't Help Falling in Love,' and also cites 'A Little Less Conversation' and 'Return to Sender' among the songs at the center of the dispute.

The lawsuits were filed by the same legal team, including attorney Richard Busch, who previously represented Marvin Gaye's estate in the 'Blurred Lines' copyright case. In the Presley complaint, the lawyers wrote that 'Suno's ravenous race to the bottom aims to make human creativity obsolete, coldly replicating without a license in seconds what takes years to learn, struggle with, maintain, and endlessly attempt to make better and perfect.' They also wrote, 'The next Elvis won't pick up a guitar.'

Suno spokesperson Cat McCormack said that 'Suno exists to help people create new, original music, not to trade on anyone's name or likeness, and we prohibit any unauthorized use of an artist's work. To protect against this, we do not allow prompts for specific artists' names and songs and work with third-party providers to screen uploaded audio files and lyrics for potential misuse. We are always working to strengthen our guardrails and we will continue to add new safeguards that protect artists and our users.'

Suno's response

The company's statement did not address the Presley lawsuit's specific allegations in detail, but it echoes language Suno has used in response to other recent suits. Suno has defended its safeguards, saying it does not permit prompts using specific artists' names or songs and uses third-party systems to screen uploaded audio and lyrics for potential misuse. The lawsuits add to a growing legal battle over whether AI companies can use copyrighted music to train generative systems and what responsibility they bear for material produced by users.

These lawsuits are the latest addition to Suno's existing list of copyright infringement accusations. Earlier this year, Sony Music Entertainment and Universal Music Group jointly filed another lawsuit claiming that Suno is still infringing on its copyrighted material for its latest v6 models. Music publisher Reservoir also filed federal lawsuits against both Suno and Anthropic on 21 October, alleging the companies effectively used its copyrighted songs to train their AI models without consent. Musician Jason Isbell and other artists filed their own lawsuit against Suno centered on alleged violations of right-of-publicity laws.

Broader legal wave

The group behind Presley's music rights has set its sights on combating AI copyright infringement. It recently filed a lawsuit against Anthropic, claiming $41 million in damages for allegedly training its AI models on the musician's works without permission. That case, filed in federal court in the Northern District of California, claims the group collectively owns or controls rights to 274 musical compositions recorded by Presley. The complaint sought up to $41.1 million in statutory copyright damages for alleged willful infringement of those 274 works.

Not all record labels and publishing companies are continuing their legal actions. Last year, Warner Music Group decided to drop its lawsuit against Suno, instead agreeing to a licensing deal. The new lawsuits come as the music industry increasingly turns to courts to establish limits on AI-generated music, particularly over the use of copyrighted works for training and the imitation of identifiable performers. The cases add to a flood of lawsuits from authors, visual artists, movie studios and record labels challenging how AI companies trained their models on existing creative works.

The Presley and Eminem lawsuits were filed on 6 November, and the plaintiffs are demanding a trial by jury. The cases are pending in federal court, with the Presley suit in the Northern District of California. The legal team, led by Richard Busch, is representing the plaintiffs in both cases. The outcome of these lawsuits could set precedents for how AI companies use copyrighted music and artists' identities in training and generation.

Frequently asked questions

What did Elvis Presley's rights holders allege in the lawsuit against Suno?

They allege Suno copied 859 Presley compositions to train its AI system and allowed users to generate music that imitates his voice and likeness, violating Tennessee's ELVIS Act.

How did Suno respond to the allegations?

Suno spokesperson Cat McCormack said the company prohibits unauthorized use of an artist's work, does not allow prompts for specific artists' names and songs, and works with third-party providers to screen for misuse.

More from this edition