Trump says he directed DOJ suit to block Alaska Senate certification
President Donald Trump said on Friday he directed the Justice Department to sue to block certification of Alaska's Senate race if Republican Dan S. Sullivan narrowly loses, over a similarly named candidate.
Photo: ABC NewsKey points
Trump said he directed the Justice Department to sue to preemptively block certification of Alaska's Senate race if Republican Dan S. Sullivan narrowly loses.
President Donald Trump said on Friday he directed the Justice Department to file a lawsuit seeking to block certification of Alaska's Senate race if Republican incumbent Dan S. Sullivan narrowly loses. The department filed the suit on Thursday in federal court in Anchorage, naming the state and its election officers as defendants over the presence of a similarly named candidate, Dan J. Sullivan Jr.
The case matters because Alaska's Senate contest could determine control of the chamber, and Inside Elections with Nathan L. Gonzales rates it a Toss-up. The suit is the Trump administration's latest move to assert a federal role in state election procedures, following a separate California lawsuit over mail ballots sent to potential noncitizens.
What the lawsuit asks the court to do
The complaint asks a federal judge to delay certifying any outcome that may be affected by voter confusion, until an investigation determines whether votes cast for Dan J. Sullivan were intended for the incumbent. It argues certification should be paused if the incumbent loses by fewer votes than Dan J. Sullivan received, under Alaska's ranked choice system.
The suit contends Dan J. Sullivan, a former U.S. Forest Service worker and elementary school teacher, launched his campaign solely to dupe voters. He filed to run on May 29 without a party designation, and has denied in interviews that his aim is to cause confusion or divert votes from the incumbent.
Election law experts said the lawsuit has no merit. Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller wrote that it is designed to win the press release rather than the litigation, calling the legal argument one of the worst he has seen. David Becker of the Center for Election Innovation and Research said the administration has no authority to tell Alaska how to certify results.
Election law experts criticise the complaint
Alaska election officials had moved to remove Dan J. Sullivan from the ballot, determining his candidacy was not in good faith and meant to confuse or mislead voters. He sued the state, a state judge ruled him eligible, and the Alaska Supreme Court upheld that ruling in June, after which the Justice Department began investigating.
Trump, speaking to reporters in Florida on Friday, said he told the department to file the suit. He described Dan J. Sullivan as the fake of the two candidates and said he believed the second Sullivan was trying to help Democrats. On Wednesday, Trump had posted on social media that he was looking at powerful legal options.
A Justice Department spokesperson said the suit was filed to ensure the candidacy does not undermine the integrity of Alaska's election. A spokesperson for Senator Sullivan said the campaign would let the complaint run its course, while Mary Peltola's campaign called the suit a despicable political threat to overturn an election.
Frequently asked questions
Why is the Justice Department suing over Alaska's Senate race?
The department filed suit to block certification if Republican Dan S. Sullivan loses by fewer votes than Dan J. Sullivan received, arguing the similarly named candidate's presence confuses voters under Alaska's ranked choice system.
Who is Dan J. Sullivan?
Dan J. Sullivan is a former U.S. Forest Service worker and elementary school teacher who filed to run without a party designation on May 29. Alaska's Supreme Court ruled in June he must appear on the ballot.
What do critics say about the lawsuit?
Notre Dame law professor Derek Muller called the legal argument one of the worst he has seen, and David Becker of the Center for Election Innovation and Research said the administration has no authority over how Alaska certifies results.


