Skip to main content

Kaer NewsSoftware

NHTSA opens recall query into Waymo school bus passing

Federal regulators investigate whether Waymo's software recall fixed robotaxis passing stopped school buses, citing a majority of incidents after the remedy.

3 min read
NHTSA opens recall query into Waymo school bus passingPhoto: Wired

Key points

NHTSA opened a recall query into whether Waymo's software update fixed robotaxis passing stopped school buses, citing a majority of incidents after the remedy.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration opened a recall query on 6 November to determine whether Waymo's software update fixed robotaxis that illegally passed stopped school buses, according to a filing. The agency's Office of Defects Investigation said a majority of reported incidents occurred after the remedy date. Passing a stopped school bus with red lights flashing and stop arm extended is illegal in all 50 states.

Waymo issued a software fix in mid-November 2025 and a voluntary recall a month later, but the government says the problems remained. The recall query will assess the adequacy of the remedy and identify the causes of conditions leading to post-remedy reports. This is the second NHTSA investigation into the issue, following an initial probe opened in October 2025.

What the recall query changes

The initial investigation began after footage showed a Waymo robotaxi maneuvering around a stopped school bus in Atlanta, Georgia, with its stop sign extended and lights flashing while unloading children. The vehicle crossed perpendicularly in front of the bus from its right side, then turned left around the front and traveled down the street. Numerous other incidents were documented in Austin, Texas, where Waymo also operates.

Austin Independent School District officials reported at least five such incidents in a letter filed with NHTSA. The NTSB, an independent federal agency, also launched its own investigation into Waymo's behavior around stopped school buses earlier this year. An NTSB report found another incident occurred in mid-January, several weeks after the supposed software fix.

Waymo completed a software update for all affected vehicles on 17 November 2025, according to the company. However, NHTSA said the majority of incidents occurred after that date. The recall query will determine whether the update actually fixed the problem, as the agency seeks to understand why the behavior continued.

Where the incidents occurred

Waymo spokesperson Dana Gallagher said in a written statement that the company has made 'significant improvements to vehicle behavior around school buses' and has not been cited for passing school buses since last March. She wrote that Waymo looks 'forward to continuing our engagement on recall processes for AV software that continues to learn and improve.' The company stressed that safety is central to its mission.

The Austin school district helped set up a half-day data collection event for Waymo's vehicles late last year, coordinating with the developer to bring school buses and stop-arm signals to an empty parking lot. The event occurred after Waymo had issued its software fix and voluntary recall, yet incidents continued. This suggests the training data may not have fully addressed the problem.

The NHTSA's Office of Defects Investigation also opened a probe into an incident where a Waymo robotaxi hit a child in Santa Monica, California, in January. Beyond the NHTSA's inquiries, the NTSB is investigating the school bus passing issue. Recall queries in the past have led to civil penalties, some costing automakers and software developers tens of millions of dollars. Waymo said it will respond to NHTSA's query once received. The company has not been cited for passing school buses since March 2026, according to its spokesperson. The investigation will continue as regulators assess whether the software remedy was adequate, with no date set for a decision.

Frequently asked questions

What is NHTSA's recall query into Waymo?

NHTSA's Office of Defects Investigation opened a recall query on 6 November to assess whether Waymo's software update fixed robotaxis passing stopped school buses. The agency said a majority of incidents occurred after the remedy date.

When did Waymo issue its software recall?

Waymo issued a software fix in mid-November 2025 and a voluntary recall a month later. The update was completed for all affected vehicles on 17 November 2025, according to the company.

Has Waymo been cited for passing school buses since the recall?

Waymo says it has received no citations for passing school buses since March 2026. However, NHTSA and the NTSB are investigating incidents that occurred after the software fix.

More from this edition