Skip to main content

Kaer NewsScience

Ancient DNA traces Germanic language origins to 4,000-year-old migration

A 4,000-year-old migration into Scandinavia may have spread Germanic languages, while Celtic origins remain debated, new DNA studies show.

4 min read
Ancient DNA traces Germanic language origins to 4,000-year-old migrationPhoto: Nature

Key points

A previously unknown migration into Scandinavia about 4,000 years ago may have brought the earliest Germanic languages, with Celtic origins still debated.

Two studies published in Nature on 4 November analysed more than 4,700 ancient human genomes and identified a previously unknown migration into Scandinavia about 4,000 years ago that may have brought the earliest Germanic languages, the common ancestor of English, German, Dutch and the Nordic tongues. The research also traced possible origins of Celtic languages, which remain debated among linguists.

The work, led by the University of Copenhagen and Leiden University, sequenced 712 new ancient genomes and combined them with published data from more than 4,000 ancient humans. The first author is Hugh McColl, an assistant professor at Copenhagen's Globe Institute, with senior authors including linguist Guus Kroonen and geneticist Eske Willerslev.

A migration nobody expected

The central finding is a population that entered Sweden around 2000 BC, probably from the Baltic Sea region, when Egypt was ruled by the pharaohs of the Middle Kingdom and Scandinavia stood on the threshold of its Bronze Age. By about 1500 BC the newcomers were widespread across Scandinavia, despite being 'archaeologically elusive' and leaving few recognisable material traces.

Until now, the origin of Germanic had been tied to an earlier wave of steppe peoples who reached Europe around 3000 BC, associated with cultures such as Corded Ware. That explanation has a timing problem: the earliest runic inscriptions date from roughly the first to the fourth century AD, leaving a gap of two or three thousand years. The new migration would place Germanic in Scandinavia some 800 years later than traditionally assumed.

McColl said the migration appears at just the time and place where the earliest Germanic would be expected to spread, describing it as a real surprise that neither archaeologists nor linguists had predicted. The authors are cautious, placing the formation of the group somewhere between Finland and northeastern Sweden, but no genomes survive from that area and period.

Goths, Lombards and Anglo-Saxons

The ancestry was present in southern Scandinavia and northern Germany around 3,000 years ago, when linguistic evidence points to exchanges with other language groups. After some 1,000 years, the population moved into central, southern and western Europe, including the British Isles, coinciding with the first appearance of runes around 2,000 years ago and the presence of this ancestry in Anglo-Saxon individuals in Britain.

The DNA also helps pin down peoples whose homelands Roman and medieval writers place in contradictory spots. The Anglo-Saxons and the Frisians of the Netherlands are genetically close to populations from northern Germany and southern Jutland, the peninsula forming mainland Denmark. The authors rule out northern Jutland, the Danish islands and Sweden as the main source of the Anglo-Saxon migration, though more samples from the North Sea coast are needed.

Most of the Lombards, who ended up in Italy, also fit Jutland or northern Germany. The Goths tell a different story: remains from the Wielbark culture in what is now Poland, dating from about 2,000 years ago, descend mainly from eastern Scandinavia, supporting a sixth-century origin legend placing the Goths' homeland in Scandinavia. Goths who settled later in Ukraine and the Iberian Peninsula carry almost entirely local ancestry, suggesting they adopted the Gothic language and identity rather than Gothic genes.

Back-migration and Old Norse

The study on Germanic also turned up a surprising back-migration of people from present-day Germany into Scandinavia, which coincided with the emergence of Old Norse, the predecessor of modern Scandinavian languages, and with the Vikings' influence on the region. During the Migration Period, broadly the fifth and sixth centuries AD, people from northern Germany moved into Denmark and southern Sweden, and by about AD 700 the earlier local ancestry had all but vanished on the Danish islands.

Linguists debate both where Celtic emerged and how it became so widespread, with some favouring an Atlantic origin overlapping with the current range of Celtic speakers in the British Isles, while other models put Celtic origins farther east in Europe. The studies show that in many cases the expansion of Germanic occurred in regions where Celtic languages were dominant, but the authors stress that DNA cannot tell you which language its owner spoke.

The method works by combining population movements with what linguists and archaeologists already know about where and when each language was in use. The authors also leave room for Germanic having spread through cultural contact, with hardly any genetic trace, and perhaps even in the opposite direction to the migrants. In the paper's own assessment, the Baltic newcomers are the simplest vector to explain, not the only possible one.

More than one billion people worldwide speak Germanic languages such as English, German and Dutch, whereas Celtic languages, including Welsh, Irish and Gaelic, are spoken by only two or three million people, mostly in northern Europe. The findings will inform ongoing debates about language spread, with further sampling from the North Sea coast needed to confirm the Anglo-Saxon picture.

Frequently asked questions

What did the ancient DNA studies find about the origin of Germanic languages?

The studies identified a previously unknown migration into Scandinavia about 4,000 years ago, possibly from the Baltic region, that may have brought the earliest Germanic languages. This ancestry spread across Europe and was present in Anglo-Saxon individuals in Britain.

How many ancient genomes were analysed in the studies?

The two studies analysed more than 4,700 ancient human genomes, including 712 newly sequenced individuals, to trace population movements and language spread.

What is the debate about the origin of Celtic languages?

Linguists debate whether Celtic emerged in an Atlantic region overlapping with current Celtic speakers in the British Isles, or farther east in Europe. The new DNA data adds evidence but does not resolve the debate.

More from this edition