Democrats face backlash after 11 miss Hegseth impeachment vote
Eleven Democrats missed the procedural vote, helping Republicans shelve Hegseth impeachment charges by a 211-204 margin on 10 November.
Photo: The GuardianKey points
Eleven Democrats missed the vote, allowing Republicans to block Hegseth impeachment by a 211-204 margin.
Democrats faced bitter criticism from within their own ranks on 11 November after 11 of their members missed a vote on the impeachment of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, helping Republicans block the effort. The absences boosted Republicans' successful move to shelve the charges on 10 November, casting a shadow over what was otherwise a triumphant week for Democrats fresh off sweeping election victories.
The procedural vote failed 211-204, sending eight articles of impeachment against Hegseth to the House Judiciary Committee. All Republicans except the articles' author, Thomas Massie of Kentucky, supported the motion to refer. Representative Katherine Clark of Massachusetts, the No. 2 Democrat in charge of tracking votes, began a closed-door party meeting on Wednesday morning scolding lawmakers who had been absent, as others chastised their colleagues in public.
Backlash from within
Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed, Democrat of Michigan, said bluntly on CNN Tuesday evening, "Show up and do your job." Representative Sydney Kamlager-Dove of California, appearing seething as she left the Capitol, told the MeidasTouch Network that Democrats had squandered the opportunity. "People should have gotten their raggedy selves up these steps to vote," she said. Representative-elect Richard Ojeda of North Carolina said the Democratic representatives "failed" by not voting.
Some senior Democrats said more anger should be directed at Hegseth and the Republicans who banded together to save his job. The articles, introduced by Massie, included charges of violating congressional authority by waging war in Iran. The effort came after voters overwhelmingly cast ballots for Democratic candidates in the 2026 midterms, largely in rebuke of the Trump administration's policies, including the war in Iran.
Many of those not in the Capitol said they support the effort to impeach Hegseth. Melanie Stansbury of New Mexico wrote on X that she was "blocked from entering the Capitol to vote due to a traffic incident and a police escort of a bus during the vote." She added that Hegseth "must be impeached now." Laura Gillen of New York and Jonathan Jackson of Illinois also wrote on X that they were stuck in traffic.
Reasons for absence
Brittany Pettersen of Colorado wrote on X that she was "denied" the ability to vote, and her office later told 9News she was stuck in traffic. Julia Brownley of California wrote on Facebook that Johnson "closed the vote" before she could make it to the House floor. Marilyn Strickland of Washington missed the vote by one minute because she was stuck behind a motorcade, her office said. Nancy Pelosi of California was in San Francisco to accept a Lifetime Advocate for Veterans Award.
Lou Correa of California wrote on Instagram that he was undergoing a medical procedure. Steven Horsford of Nevada, Haley Stevens of Michigan, and Frederica Wilson of Florida did not provide public reasons for their absence. Several Democratic lawmakers who did vote noted they were also busy with other life events but still made their way to the Capitol. Pat Ryan of New York wrote on X that he left the hospital early after back surgery to cast his vote.
Congressman Glenn Ivey, a Maryland Democrat, called the absence of the 11 lawmakers "certainly disappointing," but said there would be "other chances" to advance impeachment efforts. In an interview, Ivey said he was "absolutely" supportive of renewing the push when Democrats regain control of both chambers in January. At the same time, he argued that voters made clear that concerns about the cost of living remain their top priority.
What happens next
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries declined to tell reporters whether Democrats would pursue impeachment after assuming the majority in January, saying they would have that conversation "at the appropriate time." Republicans, for their part, appear to be taking the vote as confirmation that Hegseth's position is secure. "I think it's time to move on," said Republican Rep. Burgess Owens of Utah. "He's got a president who believes in him."
Massie told reporters after the vote that he was "not surprised, but disappointed." He suggested that if Democrats tried to impeach Hegseth on different charges, such as for firings or withholding Ukraine aid, they might be able to gain Republican support. But he also said Republicans did not learn from the midterm results. "They all know they lost the election over this war, and they're still voting for it," he said.
Hegseth defended himself Tuesday morning in a rare news conference, calling the impeachment charges a "farce" put forward by a "disgruntled and defeated congressman." He said Massie's accusations should be dealt with through legislation, not impeachment. "This is not patriotism," said Hegseth. "This is sabotage." Had the House measure passed, it would have set up a trial in the Senate, where a two-thirds majority would have been required to remove him.
Frequently asked questions
Why did the Hegseth impeachment vote fail?
The vote failed 211-204 because 11 Democrats were absent, giving Republicans the numbers to refer the articles to committee. All Republicans except Thomas Massie supported the motion.
What were the impeachment charges against Hegseth?
The articles accused Hegseth of violating federal law and the Constitution, including directing troops into war with Iran without authorization, overseeing deadly strikes on suspected drug-smuggling boats, and leading an operation to remove Venezuela's president.


