Duterte defense opens evidence with Davao assessor on Day 40
Defense counsel begins presenting evidence in Sara Duterte's impeachment trial on 9 November, calling Davao City Assessor Jaime Adalin as first witness.
Photo: RapplerKey points
The defense opened its evidence on 9 November with Davao City Assessor Jaime Adalin testifying on Duterte's declared properties.
The defense team of Vice President Sara Duterte began presenting evidence in her impeachment trial on Monday, 9 November, with Davao City Assessor Engineer Jaime Adalin as its first witness, on the 40th day of proceedings. Adalin testified on tax declarations and tax maps in the Davao Region, according to Rappler's live coverage.
The trial had been suspended on 13 October to give way to Senate committee hearings on the proposed 2027 national budget, resuming nearly a month later. Adalin confirmed that the properties listed in Duterte's statements of assets, liabilities, and net worth (SALNs) match those in the tax declarations presented by the defense.
First witness testifies
Adalin testified that the Barangay 74-A residential property listed in Duterte's 2024 SALN, with an assessed value of P82,046 and a market value of P2.5 million, is the same property reflected in the tax declaration presented by the defense. He also clarified that Barangay 74-A and Matina Crossing refer to the same location.
Prosecution counsel Benjamin Tolosa Jr. questioned Adalin about his alleged participation in an all-expenses-paid trip to China sponsored by the Chinese consulate in November 2025, seeking to test his credibility. Adalin said he could not recall the trip, and confirmed that then-Mayor Sara Duterte appointed him Davao City assessor in 2017.
Adalin said he did not check if Duterte owned other properties in Barangay 74-A, explaining that he only examined documents specified in the subpoena. He said it is possible that the property covered by a transfer certificate of title ending 0775 was the same one listed in Duterte's 2024-2025 SALNs, but he could not say for certain without further verification.
Corporate counsel delayed
The defense had planned to call Gencorp Industries Incorporated corporate counsel Suzette Balucanag-Punay, who was expected to testify on Duterte's alleged business interests in Gencorp and Metro City Chow Foods. She will not attend Monday's trial due to a scheduled magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan, with House lead prosecutor Representative Gerville Luistro saying she would likely appear on Wednesday.
A manifestation dated 4 November showed the defense intends to present corporate, local government, and banking officials as witnesses. The defense asked the Senate impeachment court to issue subpoenas duces tecum and ad testificandum to Balucanag-Punay, directing her to bring certified true copies of the companies' general information sheets and audited financial statements from 2022 to 2025.
Senate Secretary Renato Bantug Jr. said the subpoenas had been served to 21 witnesses, while Senate impeachment court spokesperson Reginald Tongol said 22 of the 24 subpoenas requested by the defense have been served. The defense also sought subpoenas for three Davao City government employees, a barangay chairperson, and at least 16 bank officials.
Sole remaining article
Article 2, which concerns allegations of unexplained wealth against Duterte, is the only remaining impeachment article after the House prosecution panel withdrew the three other articles. The defense earlier asked the court to subpoena former law school dean Ralph Sarmiento as its first witness, but Sarmiento declined, saying he wanted to preserve the independence of his constitutional law scholarship.
Prosecutors cited findings of forensic financial analyst Alexander Cabrera, who estimated that Duterte may have at least P817.87 million in unexplained assets, with broader projections reaching more than P1.5 billion. Chief prosecutor Luistro urged Duterte to take the witness stand, saying she is the only person who can directly explain the allegations against her, while defense counsel Michael Poa said it is too early to discuss that possibility.
Frequently asked questions
Who was the first defense witness in Sara Duterte's impeachment trial?
Davao City Assessor Engineer Jaime Adalin was the first defense witness, testifying on 9 November about tax declarations and tax maps in the Davao Region, confirming properties listed in Duterte's SALNs match those in the tax declarations.
Why was the impeachment trial suspended?
The trial was suspended on 13 October to give way to Senate committee hearings on the proposed 2027 national budget. It resumed on 9 November, marking Day 40 of the proceedings.
What is the only remaining impeachment article against Sara Duterte?
Article 2, which concerns allegations of unexplained wealth against Duterte, is the only remaining impeachment article after the House prosecution panel withdrew the three other articles.


