Victoria court gives Erin Patterson life without parole after appeal fails
Victoria's Court of Appeal on 30 October rejected Erin Patterson's bid to overturn her triple-murder convictions and resentenced her to life in prison with no parole for the deadly mushroom lunch.
Photo: The GuardianKey points
Erin Patterson lost her appeal against triple-murder convictions and was resentenced to life in prison without parole on 30 October 2026.
Erin Patterson has lost her appeal against triple-murder convictions and been resentenced to life in prison with no chance of release, after Victoria's Court of Appeal delivered its ruling on 30 October 2026. The court dismissed her appeal against the convictions and accepted prosecutors' argument that her original sentence was too lenient, removing the 33-year non-parole period that had previously applied.
The ruling matters because it closes off Patterson's attempt to overturn convictions for murdering Don and Gail Patterson and Heather Wilkinson, and attempting to murder Ian Wilkinson, over a beef Wellington lunch laced with death cap mushrooms at her Leongatha home in 2023. Previously she had been eligible for parole after 33 years; now she will never be released, making her only the second Australian woman given a life sentence without parole.
What the ruling changed
Justices Lesley Taylor, Stephen McLeish and Peter Kidd heard arguments from Patterson's legal team and prosecutors in August before handing down their decision. Patterson, 52, did not attend the 15-minute hearing in person and showed no emotion on the video feed as McLeish explained why the appeal failed and how the director of public prosecutions succeeded in securing a longer sentence.
McLeish said the court granted leave to appeal on the first two grounds but dismissed the appeal itself, and rejected the five other grounds raised by her lawyers. He said the court also granted the director of public prosecutions' appeal against the sentence, because the original sentence did not properly reflect the seriousness of her offending.
The court found Patterson sustained an intent to murder all four people for three weeks, from the time they were invited to the lunch, through the meal itself, and during the protracted suffering and deaths that followed. McLeish described the offending as carefully planned and deliberate, involving an elaborate series of deceptions including false cancer claims, denying she had foraged mushrooms, and lying about where the mushrooms came from.
The seven grounds rejected
Patterson's lawyers argued seven grounds for appeal, including that jurors staying in the same Traralgon hotel as police and prosecutors during their seven-day sequestration represented a catastrophic failure of the justice system. Her barrister Richard Edney called it an inexplicable failure of process. The court noted jury keepers reported no contact had occurred, which McLeish said was significant because it stood against an argument otherwise based on conjecture.
Other grounds included that trial judge Christopher Beale erred in ruling photos and videos of mushrooms found on an SD card were inadmissible, that prosecutors grilled Patterson unfairly over eight days in the witness box, and that 35 errors occurred in the prosecution's closing address. Prosecutors dismissed the concerns as baseless. The trial in Morwell lasted 11 weeks and heard from more than 50 witnesses.
Director of public prosecutions Brendan Kissane KC argued the sentence was manifestly inadequate, saying that even though Patterson would be in her 80s by the time she was eligible for parole, the sentence remained too lenient. Asked whether a longer non-parole period would essentially mean she dies behind bars, Kissane accepted it had its harsh aspect but said that was outweighed by the seriousness of the offending.
Few legal avenues remain
Patterson has become only the second Australian woman to receive a life sentence without parole. The first was NSW abattoir worker Katherine Knight, who stabbed her de facto husband John Price 37 times in February 2000. Sentencing Justice Christopher Beale, now retired, had previously resisted calls to jail Patterson without parole, finding her case was so infamous she was likely to find custody more onerous than others.
Legal researcher Christopher Corns said the general principle in Victoria is that an appellant can only have one appeal under the section Patterson used, though 2019 reforms permit a second appeal in rare circumstances involving fresh and compelling evidence. He said it was most unlikely Patterson could use that avenue, because significant evidence would have been turned up by now. Her only remaining hope, he said, is the High Court of Australia.
Criminal law barrister Nick Papas KC said High Court appeals are generally very difficult to succeed, requiring a fundamental failure in how Court of Appeal judges interpreted the law, not simply a perceived mistake. Cardinal George Pell had his convictions quashed by the High Court in 2020 after his appeal was first rejected by Victoria's Court of Appeal. Patterson must now apply to the High Court for leave to appeal if she wishes to continue fighting.
Frequently asked questions
What did the Court of Appeal decide in Erin Patterson's case?
On 30 October 2026, Victoria's Court of Appeal dismissed all seven grounds of Erin Patterson's appeal against her triple-murder convictions and resentenced her to life in prison without parole, removing her previous 33-year non-parole period.
Why did the court increase Erin Patterson's sentence?
The court found Patterson sustained murderous intent for nearly three weeks and her offending was carefully planned and deliberate, involving elaborate deceptions. Justice Stephen McLeish said the original sentence did not properly reflect the seriousness of her offending.
What legal options does Erin Patterson have now?
Patterson's remaining avenue is applying to the High Court of Australia for leave to appeal. Legal researcher Christopher Corns said a second appeal to Victoria's Court of Appeal is unlikely, as it would require fresh and compelling evidence.


