Skip to main content

Kaer NewsSoftware

Google requires AI tools for school Search, drawing criticism

Google will disable Search for schools that don't enable AI tools, sparking backlash from educators and politicians on 3 November.

4 min read
Google requires AI tools for school Search, drawing criticismPhoto: Wired

Key points

Google will disable Search for schools that do not enable AI tools, drawing criticism from educators and politicians.

Google announced that schools using its K-12 software will not be able to use Search unless they opt in to using AI tools, drawing immediate criticism from educators, parents, and politicians across the US. The decision ties AI Overviews and AI Mode to traditional search, leaving schools with no way to disable the AI features without losing Search entirely.

Chris Phillips, vice president for education at Google, said that 'Search and AI are deeply integrated,' so if a student's school doesn't opt in to using AI tools like Gemini, then students 'will not have access to search, and they'll see a message from their school that indicates it's not available.' The announcement came on Election Day, drawing sharp criticism from left-leaning politicians.

Backlash from politicians

Senator Bernie Sanders accused Google in an X post of 'extortion,' writing that 'Google is threatening schools: if you stop your students from using AI, we will cut off your access to Google Search.' Senator Richard Blumenthal said Google is 'more concerned with forcing Gemini into schools than enabling students to succeed.' Former Federal Trade Commission chair Lina Khan called the move anticompetitive, citing multiple antitrust rulings against Google.

New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani commented, 'No corporation should have the power to dictate how we teach our children.' The backlash reflects broader concerns about AI in education, where educators worry that AI Overviews could dissuade students from finding answers themselves. For millions of students required to use Chromebooks and Google education tools, switching search engines isn't a simple fix.

Google defended its decision, saying it was responding to schools' feedback. In a post on X, the company said that Gemini, Gemini Notebook, and Search will be off by default, and schools can choose to enable them individually. 'We know there's concern about students using AI to shortcut schoolwork, and schools have told us they want control,' Google wrote.

Schools seek workarounds

Educators remain skeptical. Dominique Johnson, part of an Oregon community group called Lake Oswego Parents for Responsible Technology, said, 'We were flabbergasted. This move makes things even more difficult for school districts that have determined AI is harmful to foundational learning.' An IT administrator for an elementary-middle school had earlier requested a way to block AI Overviews, writing that students need to 'navigate search results, examine sources, and draw their own conclusions.'

Without an official way to disable AI Overviews, schools have turned to technical work-arounds, including modifying search URLs and adopting browser extensions. Fairfax County Public Schools in Virginia recently developed its own extension. But these loopholes could stop functioning if Google changes how its search results are delivered, leaving schools in a precarious position.

DuckDuckGo is courting schools frustrated by Google's AI restrictions. On X, founder and CEO Gabriel Weinberg pointed to documentation explaining how schools can switch their default search engine to DuckDuckGo, adding 'get in touch for help.' Chief public affairs officer Kamyl Bazbaz wrote, 'Forcing AI on school children: how a monopolist behaves when they think people are powerless. Prove Google wrong.'

DuckDuckGo offers options to disable AI features in its search and browser settings, and a dedicated website, noai.duckduckgo.com, where AI-assisted answers and AI-generated images are turned off. The company reported earlier this year that its app installs were up 30% as users rejected being force-fed Google's AI Search. Spokesperson Allison Goodman said, 'I wouldn't expect to see a Google-style DuckDuckGo Classroom anytime soon, but ideally, we'll have special resources just for educators looking to make a switch.'

Google's push to make AI Overviews a prominent part of search has already come at a cost. Recently, shares of parent company Alphabet suffered their worst single-day selloff after the company reported weaker-than-expected search ad sales. A big cause was increased usage of AI Overviews and AI Mode, which aren't packed with many ads yet.

For schools, the dilemma over search may be just beginning. Los Angeles Unified says it is still reviewing the potential implications of Google's announcement. Some education technology experts argue that schools should abandon Google search altogether, or at least do a better job teaching students to question the validity of AI answers. Stephen Aguilar, who coleads the Center for Generative AI and Society at USC, said, 'Under-resourced districts will grit their teeth and say, We don't have the capacity to dig in our heels and not use Google.'

Google is developing a 'Guided Learning' tool for student accounts in Search, which is supposed to walk students through the process of solving a problem rather than just handing them the answer. If a student is struggling with a math problem, for example, the feature may prompt them to refresh their memory about the rules for dividing exponents. Parent advocates plan to push districts to look elsewhere, with Karolle Rabarison of Schools Beyond Screens saying, 'This move just continues a well-established pattern of big tech companies pushing products into classrooms. It's not going to work anymore.'

Frequently asked questions

Why is Google disabling Search for schools that don't enable AI?

Google says Search and AI are deeply integrated, so schools must opt in to AI tools like Gemini to use Search. The company argues this gives schools more choice, but critics call it extortion.

What are schools doing to block AI Overviews?

Schools are using technical workarounds like modifying search URLs and browser extensions. Fairfax County Public Schools developed its own extension, but these may stop working if Google changes its search delivery.

What alternatives do schools have to Google Search?

DuckDuckGo is offering schools a search engine with AI features disabled, and a dedicated noai.duckduckgo.com site. The company reported a 30% rise in app installs as users sought alternatives.

More from this edition