Skip to main content

Kaer NewsPolitics

Judge blocks Trump from closing East Potomac Park golf course

US District Judge Ana Reyes temporarily blocked the closure of East Potomac Park and its golf course, preserving public access until 28 November.

4 min read
Judge blocks Trump from closing East Potomac Park golf coursePhoto: Fox News

Key points

A federal judge temporarily blocked the closure of East Potomac Park and its golf course, keeping it open to the public until 28 November.

US District Judge Ana Reyes on Saturday temporarily blocked the Trump administration from closing East Potomac Park and its golf course in Washington, DC, hours before the planned shutdown. The temporary restraining order, issued in a 30-page decision, prevents the closure that was set for 15 November and lasts until 28 November.

Reyes ruled that the administration's justifications for closing the 106-year-old course were pretextual and that the government violated at least two federal laws 'to meet an arbitrary deadline.' She wrote that closing the park would 'irreparably harm' the plaintiffs, the DC Preservation League, and 'runs counter to the public interest in utilising national parkland.'

Reyes finds pretext

The order does not require the administration to actively manage the golf course, but it specifies that the administration 'cannot use the absence of golf operations as a reason to exclude the public from the Course.' The park must remain open for 'routine, temporary closures consistent with the Course's historical operating practices' and for 'articulated, imminent threats to public safety.'

The legal dispute dates back to February, when the DC Preservation League and two local golfers sued over redevelopment plans. President Donald Trump announced in October that the course would be closed for 15 months from 15 November for renovations, calling the current course 'Trash Island' and promising to create 'one of the Best and Most Spectacular Golf Courses anywhere in the World.'

The dispute escalated in October when the National Park Service cut down more than 500 trees over a weekend without notifying Reyes until 15 hours before work began. Reyes later called the tree removal 'bad faith' and ordered a stop to further felling, requiring three business days' notice for any other permanent changes.

Tree cutting spree

In her ruling, Reyes noted the speed of the tree cutting as evidence against the administration's safety claims. 'If public safety were at risk, NPS would have taken a step—any step—to address the safety issues it knew about. Recall that within just ten days, NPS was able to plan, muster the resources and staff, and execute felling over 400 healthy trees,' she wrote.

The administration argued the park had to close for repairs, including a deteriorating seawall that posed an 'imminent threat to public safety.' But the National Park Service has no plan in place to fix the seawall, and the new seawall is expected to cost more than $300 million and take at least two-and-a-half years, according to a proposal submitted to the US Commission of Fine Arts.

Lawyers for the preservation group and golfers said the administration had manufactured a situation where the course would no longer have an operator, the National Links Trust, as of 15 November, and found areas of disrepair to justify the closure. Reyes pushed the Justice Department on whether the president's order to shutter the park was the real reason for the closure date.

Seawall dispute

In a court hearing on Friday, Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward said he 'would be shocked to learn there is a contract' with golf course architect Tom Fazio or any affiliated entities finalising the new course plans. The administration's notice published Friday said it will solicit a contract for work related to 20,700 linear feet of shoreline and seawall infrastructure.

Reyes has also opened an inquiry into whether Justice Department attorneys 'have made misrepresentations to the court and otherwise violated ethical rules,' including whether giving late notice about the renovation plans was 'done in bad faith.' She said she would carry out the inquiry with a special master, an independent third party.

The Justice Department said in a statement that the order does not preclude planning for the development of a world class golf course. 'The Department of Justice will always vociferously defend the Trump Administration's agenda in court,' a spokesperson said. The order remains in effect until 28 November, when further proceedings are expected.

Frequently asked questions

Why did the judge block the closure of East Potomac Park?

Judge Ana Reyes found the administration's justifications for closure were pretextual and violated federal laws. She ruled that closing the park would irreparably harm the plaintiffs and run counter to the public interest in utilising national parkland.

How long does the temporary restraining order last?

The order lasts until 28 November. It prevents the closure of East Potomac Park and its golf course, which was scheduled to begin on 15 November for a 15-month renovation.

What happens next in the legal dispute?

The judge has opened an inquiry into whether Justice Department attorneys made misrepresentations to the court. The order remains in effect until 28 November, when further proceedings are expected.

More from this edition