Judge blocks Trump's 250-foot arch after panel approves construction
US District Judge Tanya Chutkan temporarily barred construction of Trump's 250-foot triumphal arch near Arlington National Cemetery for 14 days on 5 November.
Photo: MyJoyOnlineKey points
A federal judge temporarily blocked construction of Trump's 250-foot triumphal arch for 14 days after the planning commission approved it.
US District Judge Tanya Chutkan temporarily barred the Trump administration from beginning construction of President Donald Trump's proposed 250-foot memorial arch in Washington, delaying work for at least 14 days. The order came hours after the National Capital Planning Commission approved the project in an 8-4 vote following a lengthy public hearing.
What the ruling changes
The arch, planned for a site near Arlington National Cemetery, would tower roughly 25 stories above the ground. The project is intended to mark the nation's 250th anniversary, and its cost and funding remain unclear, with estimates as high as $100 million. Chutkan had previously ordered the administration to give her advance notice before construction began, allowing her to intervene before any work could get underway. Her latest order has thrown the project's timeline into further uncertainty, leaving the start of the three-year construction plan up in the air.
The Justice Department filed a notice with Chutkan informing her that a contractor had already done site preparation work on October 31, apparently without authorisation from the National Park Service. The department has said an initial six to eight months of construction focused on excavation and foundation work could begin within days.
Above-ground construction would start in May 2027 at the earliest, with the job expected to take 33 to 39 months in total. The arch would include an eternal flame held by a 60-foot-tall gold, winged female figure, flanked by gold flying eagles, resembling the Arc de Triomphe in Paris but standing about 25 metres taller.
Why opponents object
Opponents, including veterans, conservation groups and local officials, argue the arch would dishonor the cemetery, disrupt historic views and may be unlawful. Anne Wright, who spent 29 years in the US military and also worked in the diplomatic service, said she would try to stop the construction: "We'll tie ourselves to the bulldozer, we've got veterans in wheelchairs and we'll chain the wheelchairs to these things."
Fellow veteran John Pomeroy, who served in the Air Force for six years including during the Vietnam War and whose parents are buried at Arlington, said the arch "would lessen the solemn nature of a visit to the cemetery." He described Trump's suggestion that the arch could store military equipment as "silly" and a "half-baked idea," arguing it would be a target for terrorist attacks.
Democratic Congressman Jared Huffman argued in his statement to the commission that the arch would disrupt sightlines not just of Arlington but of the Lincoln Memorial, fracturing "a view meant to underscore the unity and sacrifice of the American people, and doing that with a structure we often associate with emperors or kings who built grand arches as tributes to themselves." "This is a tribute to Donald Trump," Huffman added.
What happens next
D.C. City Council member Phil Mendelson, who also serves on the planning panel, said the project had not received required approval from Congress, nor had Congress appropriated any money for it. Lawsuits have been filed against the plans, raising concerns about the environment, traffic congestion and safety, and there is a disagreement over whether congressional approval is needed.
Mark Paoletta, the chairman of the NCPC and one of the Trump appointees, said at Thursday's meeting that the president understood "it's important to our national identity to display who we are through grand monuments." He added that the arch would honour the nation, its veterans and "provide the sacred ground of Arlington National Cemetery with the monumental gateway it deserves."
Democrats, riding high after their historic midterm victories on Tuesday, have vowed to kill the project when they take control of the House and Senate in January. "The Great Gatsby party is over," warned California Democratic Representative Jared Huffman, just hours before the federal panel convened to vote on Trump's ambitious project.
Frequently asked questions
Why did the judge block the arch construction?
Judge Tanya Chutkan issued a temporary restraining order to pause construction for 14 days, allowing time to consider legal challenges. The order came after the National Capital Planning Commission approved the project.
How tall is the proposed arch?
The arch is planned to be 250 feet (76 metres) tall, roughly 25 stories high, making it nearly as prominent as the US Capitol.
What are the opponents' main arguments?
Opponents argue the arch would dishonor Arlington National Cemetery, disrupt historic views, and may be unlawful without congressional approval. They also raise concerns about traffic, safety, and the cost, estimated up to $100 million.


