Judge blocks Trump plan to close Washington golf course for renovation
US District Judge Ana C. Reyes barred the government from closing East Potomac Park for a planned 15-month golf course overhaul, citing environmental law violations.
Photo: Egypt IndependentKey points
A federal judge blocked the closure of East Potomac Golf Links, ruling the administration's reasons were pretextual and likely violated environmental law.
US District Judge Ana C. Reyes barred the government from closing East Potomac Park for a planned 15-month golf course overhaul, issuing a temporary restraining order on Saturday night, November 14. The order prevents the government from closing the park and its golf course during their usual public hours through November 28 or until further court action. The judge found that the administration's stated reasons for shutting the site were 'pretextual' and that its actions likely violated federal environmental and administrative laws.
Reyes wrote that the closure would 'irreparably harm' the individual golfers and preservationists who challenged the project. 'The Government proposes to close a historic park, daily enjoyed by Washingtonians of all stripes, indefinitely,' she wrote. The ruling came just hours before the course was due to close Sunday for the renovation, which Trump had announced would begin that day despite the legal challenge initiated in February by the DC Preservation League and two local golfers.
Court finds procedural failures
The legal rationale of her ruling turned on the National Park Service's failures to take certain steps before the overhaul that she found to be required by law, such as providing notice to the public of the plan and soliciting their comment on it. 'Notice-and-comment rulemaking is not impracticable merely because NPS wishes to accommodate President Trump and close the Park by November 15,' she wrote. The judge said the order is in effect 'through November 28, 2026, or further order from the Court, whichever comes first.'
The dispute intensified in October after more than 400 trees were removed from the grounds. Reyes subsequently blocked further tree removal and imposed additional notice requirements on major changes to the site. During that hearing, Reyes said, 'More than just being upset and furious right now, I am just beyond disappointed with the government.' The administration claimed the removals were necessary and not tied to Trump's desired renovation, a claim Reyes said she was 'skeptical' of.
Dispute over tree removals
Trump first publicly proposed taking over and expanding the municipal golf course in May. His plan involves transforming East Potomac Golf Links into a championship-level venue designed by golf architect Tom Fazio, who has worked on several of the president's private courses. Trump toured the grounds with Interior Secretary Doug Burgum and Fazio in June. The plaintiffs argue that the changes would alter the character of the historic public facility and reduce access for ordinary golfers.
The Justice Department said in a statement Saturday that the judge acknowledged that the National Park Service can limit access to its facilities where the public is at risk of harm. 'Nothing in the Court's order precludes planning for the development of a world class golf course to continue,' it said. 'The Department of Justice will always vociferously defend the Trump Administration's agenda in court.' The department had unsuccessfully tried to remove Reyes from the case.
Catherine Carroll, a senior legal adviser at Democracy Forward, which is representing the plaintiffs, praised the ruling. 'We are grateful that once again, a court has intervened to prevent irreparable harm caused by the Trump-Vance administration's pursuit of another one of the president's vanity projects,' she said. 'The administration's inexplicable drive to destroy East Potomac Park would have taken away a treasured park that could never be replaced.'
Justice Department responds
Reyes had signaled throughout a five-hour court hearing Friday that she was likely to issue some stoppage for the park closure. Justice Department lawyer Adam Gustafson argued that the entire East Potomac Park, which includes three golf courses, a miniature course, bike riding lanes and other recreational areas, was being closed because of safety factors. Reyes pointed out that safety had not been part of the discussion over the closure for months and that ending the lease felt more like an action that provided a premise for the closure.
The park's redevelopment is one of multiple projects in the nation's capital that Trump has championed to remake the city, including a large memorial arch, a White House ballroom and the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts. The ruling is another legal setback for Trump's efforts to reshape parts of Washington. The order does not require the National Park Service to operate the golf course, but keeps the park accessible to the public through November 28.
Frequently asked questions
What did the judge rule about the golf course closure?
US District Judge Ana C. Reyes issued a temporary restraining order on November 14 preventing the government from closing East Potomac Park and its golf course through November 28, finding the closure would cause irreparable harm.
Why did the judge block the redevelopment plan?
Reyes found the administration's stated reasons for the closure were 'pretextual' and that its actions likely violated federal environmental and administrative laws, including failing to provide public notice and solicit comments.
When was the golf course scheduled to close?
The administration had planned to close East Potomac Golf Links on November 15 for a 15-month overhaul to transform it into a championship-level venue designed by golf architect Tom Fazio.


