US judge tosses case against ex-FBI officials in Hunter Biden probe
Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui dismissed charges against Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides on 2 November, calling the prosecution 'weaponization'.
Photo: The Jerusalem PostKey points
A federal judge threw out charges against two former FBI officials accused of lying to Congress, citing a rushed and politically motivated prosecution.
US Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui dismissed criminal charges against two former FBI officials on 2 November, ruling that prosecutors had not shown sufficient evidence that they knowingly made false statements to Congress. The case against Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides was thrown out at an early stage, with Faruqui calling the prosecution 'weaponization' of federal law enforcement.
The charges stemmed from testimony the officials gave to the House Judiciary Committee in 2023 about their knowledge of a laptop that belonged to Hunter Biden, which was in FBI possession ahead of the 2020 election. Faruqui said the investigation was rushed and marked by 'critical mistakes,' noting that many of the supposedly false statements were not false.
Rushed investigation
Faruqui pointed to the timing of the charges, which were brought two weeks before the midterm elections. 'I will not bury my head in the sand and pretend that I cannot read a calendar,' he said in court. The judge said high-ranking officials sought to charge the case last month to influence the elections.
The investigation began the day after President Donald Trump delivered a primetime address in which he called for the prosecution of individuals involved in the FBI's shuttered Foreign Influence Task Force. FBI Director Kash Patel mandated the inquiry and closely monitored its progress, according to testimony from FBI agent Bryan Witt.
Witt testified that the agency investigated Floris and Benavides for months before focusing on their 2023 testimony. Both officials served in supervisory positions at the task force. Faruqui noted that the government did not show that the officials knew at the time that some statements might have been false, a necessary element of the crime.
Political timing
Faruqui criticized the Justice Department's handling of the case, including its decision to proceed through a criminal complaint rather than seek a grand jury indictment. He said the government offered an incomprehensible 'word salad' justification for why the pair might have lied, arguing they wanted to downplay the task force's role in handling the laptop.
The judge also noted that he had signed off on some 400 criminal complaints in the last five years but had never held such a hearing or ruled against the government during one. He said the decision to proceed with a complaint, coupled with the timing, made him concerned about the political nature of the investigation.
Faruqui said statements by Judiciary Committee majority general counsel Steve Castor about the alleged lies were 'inadequate, incorrect and not credible.' Castor talked about the impact of the supposed lies without having attended the Benavides interview or reviewed the transcript of either interview. The ruling is a setback for the Justice Department, which has faced difficulties securing indictments in politically sensitive cases in Washington. The government could still appeal Faruqui's ruling to Chief Judge James Boasberg or seek a grand jury indictment of the pair.
Faruqui said it was 'self-evident' that the government was avoiding presenting the case before a grand jury, noting he had to pause proceedings several times last week for the government to present grand jury indictments, including one failed one. 'It turns out ham sandwiches are harder to indict these days,' he said.
Frequently asked questions
What charges were dismissed against the former FBI officials?
Charges of making false statements to Congress about their knowledge of a laptop belonging to Hunter Biden. The judge found no evidence they knowingly lied.
Why did the judge call the prosecution 'weaponization'?
The judge said the investigation was rushed, politically motivated, and timed to influence the midterm elections. He noted it began after President Trump's primetime address and was mandated by FBI Director Kash Patel.
Can the Justice Department still pursue the case?
Yes, the government could appeal the ruling or seek a grand jury indictment. The judge noted the government had avoided presenting the case to a grand jury.


