Malaysia's king warns against disputing Najib's house arrest order
Sultan Ibrahim said on 7 November the conditional pardon for Najib Razak is unambiguous, warning any dispute would defy his decree.
Photo: Malay MailKey points
Malaysia's king said Najib Razak's conditional pardon is unambiguous and warned that disputing it would defy his decree.
Malaysia's king Sultan Ibrahim Sultan Iskandar said on 7 November that the conditional royal pardon allowing former prime minister Najib Razak to serve the remainder of his prison sentence under house arrest is clear and unambiguous, warning that any attempt to dispute the order would amount to defying the monarch's decree. The king's assertion comes a day after the Attorney-General's Chambers called for Najib's transfer to house arrest to be temporarily suspended, citing complex legal questions over the interpretation of the royal pardon and its implications for a separate prison sentence imposed on the former leader.
In a statement on 7 November, Sultan Ibrahim said that the conditional pardon was not related to any of Najib's other cases and that all the conditions stipulated in the order had been fulfilled. "This conditional pardon order is clear, explicit and without any ambiguity, and is not related to any other cases involving him," the king said. "There should be no confusion in its interpretation, nor should there be prolonged uncertainty over the implementation of the decision that has been granted."
King's decree
The king also said that the power to grant pardons is a royal prerogative under Article 42 of Malaysia's Federal Constitution. "The exercise of this power must be respected in accordance with the position of the Constitutional Monarchy and the principle of the rule of law," Sultan Ibrahim said. "Given that all the conditions stipulated in the conditional pardon order have been fulfilled, any argument disputing the order would amount to defying the command of His Majesty the Yang di-Pertuan Agong." The statement did not explicitly direct the AGC to withdraw its position or reverse the proposed temporary suspension of Najib's house arrest.
The king's remarks follow a dispute between Najib's lawyers and the AGC on Friday over the implementation of Najib's conditional pardon, which would allow him to serve the remainder of his sentence in the SRC International corruption case under house arrest. The AGC called for a temporary suspension of the house arrest arrangement, arguing that further legal clarification was needed before it could be implemented. The AGC said there were two possible interpretations of the pardon following Najib's payment of a RM50 million (US$12.3 million) fine.
The AGC said further clarification was needed on whether Najib's payment of the fine meant he must continue serving his sentence under house arrest until Aug 23, 2028, or whether the sentence should be considered completed. The distinction is significant because of Najib's separate conviction in the 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB) case, for which he was sentenced to 15 years in prison, the AGC said. "This is particularly relevant to the court order stipulating that the sentence in the 1MDB case must commence after the completion of the prison sentence in the SRC International case," the AGC said.
Legal questions
The AGC mentioned that determining when the SRC International sentence ends would therefore have implications for when the separate 1MDB prison term should commence. It also noted that Najib's application for a stay of execution of the 1MDB sentence and fine pending appeal had been dismissed by the High Court on Oct 14. Describing the situation as unprecedented, the AGC said clear and definitive legal clarification was necessary before further steps could be taken to implement the royal pardon. It maintained that the proposed temporary suspension was not intended to question or set aside the king's decree, but to ensure that the pardon and relevant court orders were implemented in accordance with the law.
Najib's lawyers rejected the AGC's position on Friday, arguing that there was no lawful basis for their client to remain in prison. They demanded that Najib be released immediately into house arrest, in a statement. The AGC, in its statement, raised questions on how Malaysia enforces royal pardons and court orders, with the outcome potentially determining when Najib begins serving a separate 15-year prison sentence linked to the multibillion-dollar 1MDB corruption scandal. Najib's fine was paid on Nov 6 by his party UMNO, which raised the money through public donations.
On the same day, Home Minister Saifuddin Nasution Ismail gazetted Najib's Langgak Duta residence as a prison under the Prison Act 1995, a legal step towards allowing him to serve his sentence under house arrest. The security presence outside Najib's residence was nowhere to be seen on 7 November, a day after the Taman Duta property was placed under tight security ahead of his anticipated return under house arrest. According to Astro Awani, no police officers or Prisons Department vehicles were visible outside the Jalan Langgak Duta residence, while yellow security tape restricting access to the property had also been removed.
Political pressure
Several Umno leaders in Johor have lodged a police report over the delay in implementing Najib's house arrest, as Umno Youth chief Datuk Dr Muhammad Akmal Saleh called for similar reports to be filed nationwide. Pontian Umno chief Datuk Seri Ahmad Maslan, who is also a party supreme council member, lodged the report at the Benut police station at 12.30pm on 7 November, accompanied by his deputy Mohd Sumali Reduan, division vice-chief Jamaludin Abd Majid and several grassroots leaders. "A police report was lodged over the delay in implementing the house arrest order for Najib, which should have been carried out," Ahmad said in a Facebook post.
Dr Akmal said Umno Youth branches at state and division levels would lodge police reports to seek an investigation into whether any laws had been breached in delaying the implementation of the royal pardon and related court order. In a statement on 7 November, he urged the government to immediately implement the conditional pardon granted by His Majesty, Sultan Ibrahim, maintaining that all stipulated conditions had been fulfilled. "On November 6, all conditions were met. The RM50 million fine was paid at the Kuala Lumpur High Court, which then issued a sealed order allowing Datuk Seri Najib to serve the remainder of his sentence under house arrest. The Home Ministry also gazetted his residence as a prison under Section 3 of the Prisons Act 1995," Akmal said.
The prospect of Najib returning home has also exposed political tensions within Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim's coalition government. At a press conference in Putrajaya on Nov 6, Transport Minister Anthony Loke warned that allowing Najib to serve his sentence under house arrest could send "the wrong message to future generations". Loke reiterated that he would resign immediately after Najib returned home to protest against the move to allow the house arrest. Najib, 73, has been serving a prison sentence since August 2022 following his conviction for offences involving RM42 million in SRC International funds.
His original 12-year sentence was reduced to six years under a partial royal pardon in 2024, while his RM210 million fine was cut to RM50 million. A subsequent conditional pardon granted on September 18 this year allowed him to serve the remaining term under house arrest, subject to payment of the fine and compliance with stipulated conditions. The pardon allows Najib to serve the remainder of his SRC International sentence under house arrest until August 23, 2028, subject to payment of the RM50 million fine and compliance with other conditions. No timeline was provided for a resolution of the legal dispute.
Frequently asked questions
What did Malaysia's king say about Najib's conditional pardon?
Sultan Ibrahim said on 7 November that the conditional pardon is clear and unambiguous, and warned that any attempt to dispute it would amount to defying the monarch's decree.
Why did the AGC suspend Najib's house arrest?
The AGC called for a temporary suspension, citing legal questions over whether payment of the RM50 million fine ended Najib's SRC International sentence or allowed him to serve it under house arrest until Aug 23, 2028.
When was Najib's fine paid and what happened next?
Najib's RM50 million fine was paid on Nov 6 by UMNO. The same day, the High Court issued an order for house arrest, but the AGC suspended it pending legal clarification.


