Skip to main content

Kaer NewsSoftware

OpenAI agrees to bar Apple trade secrets in hearing

At a 14 October hearing in San Jose, OpenAI agreed not to use trade secrets Apple claims were stolen and to collect forensic images from 14 employees' devices.

3 min read
OpenAI agrees to bar Apple trade secrets in hearingPhoto: 9to5Mac

Key points

OpenAI agreed not to use trade secrets Apple claims were stolen and to collect forensic images from 14 employees' devices, after a judge signalled he was highly likely to grant an injunction.

OpenAI agreed on 14 October not to use trade secrets that Apple claims were stolen, making the voluntary concession at a federal court hearing in San Jose, California, where US District Judge Edward Davila said he was highly likely to grant Apple a preliminary injunction against the company. The agreement also requires OpenAI to collect forensic images from 14 employees' devices that may contain Apple's confidential information, and Judge Davila will have the power to enforce it, meaning OpenAI could face court-imposed sanctions if it fails to comply with its commitments.

What the hearing changed

The concession matters because it gives Apple most of what it was seeking from Judge Davila — a guarantee that its proprietary information stays off-limits for OpenAI's own technology development — while sparing OpenAI an outright loss in its first substantive court showdown with the iPhone maker. Apple filed its trade secret misappropriation lawsuit in July.

Apple accused OpenAI, its hardware chief and a former iPhone hardware engineer of conspiring to extract confidential information from former Apple employees about product design, manufacturing, component technologies, testing methodologies and the company's supply chain. Apple claimed OpenAI is exploiting that information to advance its efforts to enter the consumer hardware market.

OpenAI has vehemently denied the allegations, arguing that Apple's lawsuit is an effort to restrain employees from leaving for a competitor and that the company seeks to cast ordinary job interviews as acts of trade secret misappropriation. In an October court filing, OpenAI said it has no need or desire for Apple's trade secrets.

OpenAI's counter-allegations against Apple

Hours before the 14 October hearing, OpenAI filed a motion alleging that a former employee — who joined OpenAI from Apple, worked there six months, then returned to Apple — sent over a hundred highly confidential files about at least one unreleased OpenAI device to personal accounts on 2 June 2026, his final day.

Those files included detailed images of unreleased devices, engineering and manufacturing data, supplier information, project files, cosmetic finish standards, and reports on coating and sealing of hardware components. OpenAI also alleged the employee made a presentation about OpenAI's plans to Apple's senior leadership, including Apple's vice president of operations in Asia.

Apple said it has policies and procedures in place to ensure new employees do not use confidential information from previous employers, and that it found no evidence to substantiate OpenAI's claims. Apple said the AI company is simply trying to distract from the significant evidence that its employees took Apple product information.

What happens next in the case

During the hearing, Judge Davila pushed back against some of Apple's demands, describing its request to inspect every device and repository that might contain its trade secrets as a huge ask. Apple's lawyer, John M. Desmarais, responded that the company would limit inspections to a small group of former employees, saying OpenAI does not have 400 bad apples but rather a few bad apples and knows who they are.

The court had partially granted Apple's request for expedited discovery the day before, giving OpenAI up to two weeks to hand over forensic evidence and materials used when interviewing former Apple employees. Chang Liu, Tang Tan, and Alyssa Peng, Liu's former Apple colleague, will need to sit for depositions after Apple receives the requested information.

OpenAI asked the court for time to investigate whether Apple possesses or used its information and, if so, to file counterclaims. The dispute arose while hundreds of Apple employees defected to OpenAI and has put a cloud over the start-up as it targets a US$1.4 trillion valuation and prepares to go public. No further hearing date has been announced. Judge Davila will decide whether to issue the preliminary injunction and retains authority to enforce OpenAI's voluntary agreement, including through court-imposed sanctions if the company fails to collect the forensic images from the 14 employees' devices.

Frequently asked questions

What did OpenAI agree to at the 14 October hearing?

OpenAI voluntarily agreed not to use trade secrets Apple claims were stolen, and to collect forensic images from 14 employees' devices that may contain Apple's confidential information. Judge Edward Davila will have the power to enforce the agreement, and OpenAI could face court-imposed sanctions if it fails to comply.

Why did Apple sue OpenAI?

Apple filed its trade secret misappropriation lawsuit in July, accusing OpenAI, its hardware chief and a former iPhone hardware engineer of conspiring to extract confidential information from former Apple employees about product design, manufacturing, component technologies, testing methodologies and supply chain, to advance OpenAI's entry into consumer hardware.

What did OpenAI allege against Apple?

OpenAI filed a motion alleging a former employee who returned to Apple sent over a hundred highly confidential files about at least one unreleased OpenAI device to personal accounts on 2 June 2026, and presented OpenAI product plans to Apple's senior leadership. Apple said it found no evidence to support these claims.

More from this edition