Skip to main content

Kaer NewsPolitics

Tusk vows no compromise in Polish court standoff

Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk vowed no compromise in the Constitutional Tribunal standoff, as the European Commission backed parliament's right to appoint judges.

5 min read
Tusk vows no compromise in Polish court standoffPhoto: The Japan Times

Key points

Polish PM Donald Tusk vowed no compromise in the Constitutional Tribunal standoff, with the European Commission backing parliament's right to appoint judges.

Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk vowed on Saturday night not to back down in the standoff over the country's Constitutional Tribunal, as the European Commission backed parliament's right to appoint new judges. "In some matters there can be no compromise," Tusk said in an address to the nation, comparing calls for reconciliation to a thief demanding to keep half the contents of a stolen handbag.

The dispute pits Tusk's government against President Karol Nawrocki over efforts to reverse judicial changes introduced by the nationalist Law and Justice (PiS) government between 2015 and 2023, which drew condemnation from European courts over concerns about judicial independence. Nawrocki, elected with PiS backing in 2025, has refused to swear in some Tribunal judges elected by the current parliamentary majority, while the court's PiS-linked leadership has prevented them from working.

Commission backs parliament

The European Commission said it was closely monitoring developments and, in a carefully worded statement, appeared to show support for Tusk's position. "The Polish Constitutional Tribunal needs to be able to function in accordance with the Polish constitution and the case law of the Court of Justice of the EU," Commissioner for Democracy, Justice and the Rule of Law Michael McGrath said. "This matters for every Polish citizen, and it is for the Polish authorities to ensure that."

McGrath added that "the Venice Commission has been clear that appointing the new judges lies within the power of the Sejm [Poland's lower house of parliament]." The Venice Commission, a European legal authority, has ruled that the president's role in swearing in judges is ceremonial and that Nawrocki is misusing it. McGrath stopped short of endorsing Friday's suspension of Tribunal President Bogdan Święczkowski and his deputy Bartłomiej Sochański, a move that triggered the latest spat.

Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, taking charge of the Tribunal, suspended Święczkowski and Sochański after they blocked judges elected by the Tusk-led parliamentary majority from work for months. On the evening of 30 October, a group of judges picked by parliament this year, but whom the president has refused to swear in, strode into the court building while riot police secured the grounds. Korwin-Piotrowska said she was suspending the court's president and his deputy for 30 days on grounds of obstructing the court's functioning.

President's plane turned around

Nawrocki denounced the move as an unlawful takeover and held talks with parliamentary leaders on Saturday, boycotted by Tusk's Civic Coalition and its government ally, the New Left. The president had been en route to Senegal, but turned his plane around and returned to Warsaw, where he and his entourage forced their way into the building, pushing Korwin-Piotrowska out of the way. Several hundred protesters gathered outside the court, including someone wearing the armour and wooden wings of a medieval Polish hussar.

Tusk also targeted Nawrocki in his address. "In a state governed by the rule of law, a politician cannot enter a court or tribunal and give orders or intimidate judges, even if he is the president," Tusk said. He pledged to ensure the Tribunal could operate independently and safely. Tusk said in a TV address on Saturday that the Constitutional Tribunal in its current format isn't independent and his government's attempts to fix it have been sabotaged by PiS and Nawrocki.

The prime minister accused the opposition of stirring up violence in an attempt to destroy the rule of law as the political crisis continued to spiral. He spoke hours after riot police were deployed in front of the court, and two of its top judges were suspended. Tusk defended his move in an address to the nation on the night of 31 October, saying the government had "waited patiently" despite PiS's obstructionism, and that the country needed a state "capable of enforcing justice".

Showdown on 3 November

The crisis is a boon for PiS. Since 2023 the populists have been shedding voters to two far-right rival parties, Konfederacja and Korona. In August 40 MPs headed by Mateusz Morawiecki, a former prime minister, abandoned PiS to form a more moderate party, Development Plus. The standoff over the court gives PiS a chance to lead the charge against Tusk and recover its standing as the country's main opposition.

Some constitutional scholars have criticised the move. "You cannot restore the rule of law by force," Marcin Matczak, a constitutional scholar, wrote on X the evening of the confrontation. He added that Święczkowski is "the worst possible person to serve as president of the constitutional court, but there are no legal grounds for [suspending] him." Korwin-Piotrowska has convened an assembly of Tribunal judges for Tuesday, potentially setting up another confrontation over who controls the court.

A showdown awaits on 3 November, when Korwin-Piotrowska will convene the court's judges to adopt its budget. The situation remains at an impasse. Parliamentary elections are due next year, and Tusk seems to be trying to show his supporters, who have been disappointed by his failure to root PiS's appointees out of the system, that he is doing something. Nawrocki met leaders of five parties to discuss ways to resolve the crisis, including two centrist groups that are members of Tusk's ruling coalition.

Several party leaders said they wanted a "constitutional reset", a vague formula that might entail replacing all of the tribunal's judges at once. The dispute over the tribunal has its roots in PiS's attempts to take political control over the judiciary after taking office in 2015. They refused to seat five judges appointed to the Constitutional Tribunal by the previous government and instead named judges of their own. Mounting conflicts led the European Union to withhold billions of euros' worth of funds from Poland.

Frequently asked questions

What is the dispute over Poland's Constitutional Tribunal about?

The dispute pits Prime Minister Donald Tusk's government against President Karol Nawrocki over efforts to reverse judicial changes introduced by PiS between 2015 and 2023. Nawrocki has refused to swear in some Tribunal judges elected by the current parliamentary majority, while the court's PiS-linked leadership has prevented them from working.

Why did President Nawrocki turn his plane around?

Nawrocki was en route to Senegal when Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska suspended the court's president and his deputy. He turned his plane around and returned to Warsaw, where he and his entourage forced their way into the building, pushing Korwin-Piotrowska out of the way.

When is the next showdown over the court?

A showdown awaits on 3 November, when Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska will convene the court's judges to adopt its budget. The situation remains at an impasse, with parliamentary elections due next year.

More from this edition