Skip to main content

Kaer NewsWorld

Pope Leo rebukes Milei's austerity in Buenos Aires speech

Pope Leo XIV told Argentina's president the economy must serve the people, in a stinging critique on 8 November.

5 min read
Pope Leo rebukes Milei's austerity in Buenos Aires speechPhoto: The Guardian

Key points

Pope Leo XIV rebuked Milei's austerity in Buenos Aires, urging the economy to serve the people.

Pope Leo XIV delivered a stinging critique of Argentine President Javier Milei's austerity measures on 8 November, insisting growth must benefit all in a speech met with rapturous applause in Buenos Aires. "The economy must be at the service of the people, rather than people being at the service of the economy," he said on Sunday, shortly after landing in Argentina on the second leg of a Latin America tour.

Leo stressed the plight of those who, "despite hard work, nonetheless struggle to meet their household's needs." He spoke out in defence of the poor and pensioners, insisting that "particular concern be shown for those affected by illness, dependency and disability" – a veiled reference to the government's controversial cuts to disability assistance that have prompted weekly protests outside the National Congress building.

A stinging critique

The Pope also told Milei that strengthening democracy required a "willingness to listen" and the "careful use of words." Leo, 71, is on an ambitious 12-day tour of the continent, just three weeks after undergoing surgery for lung cancer. The visit is the first by a pontiff to Argentina in nearly four decades, and Leo was met with calls to help mend deep divisions in the country after three years of austerity under Milei.

Argentina is the home country of the late Pope Francis, whom Milei famously insulted for his pro-poor teachings. Leo said he was "retracing" Francis's steps. Argentines are hoping the leader of the world's 1.4 billion Catholics will help unite the country, which is bitterly divided between supporters and opponents of Milei. "Just like the World Cup unites us, hopefully the pope will too," said Liliana Deblauwe, a 68-year-old retired teacher who waited with hundreds of people to see the pope visit a monument to liberation hero Jose de San Martin.

Hundreds more chanting "Papa Leon" (Spanish for Leo) gathered outside the presidential palace, where he was hosted by Milei. Brian Inacio Rodriguez, a 26-year-old job seeker, spent five days travelling overland from Ushuaia, at the very tip of South America, to see the pontiff. He said he hoped he brought "much peace to Argentina." Leo arrived in Buenos Aires from Uruguay, where he began his first trip as pope to Latin America, the world's most Catholic continent which is becoming increasingly secular.

Milei's response

In Uruguay, he condemned drug violence and urged an end to child poverty. In Buenos Aires, he insisted on the importance of "personal integrity" in public office, stressing that "corruption undermines the confidence of citizens in their institutions." The Argentine stage of his visit aims to boost the flagging faith of a country left disappointed by Francis's failure to visit during his papacy. In a recent University of Buenos Aires poll, 57.7% of people identified as Catholic, down from about 90% in the 1960s.

Milei, 56, responded to the Pope's appeal in his own style in comments reported by the LN+ television channel. "I am not against any of those things. That is the malicious characterisation put forward by part of the political system, with the complicity of the press. I think debates should be intellectually honest, and in Argentina they are not intellectually honest," argued Milei. He said the opposition had voted for 40 government bills last year that sought to undermine macroeconomic stability, highlighting his pledge for fiscal balance.

Moving on to the positive, the President said he had been "moved" by the Pope's historic visit, describing it as "something truly overwhelming." "During the part where I have to walk alone along the red carpet to wait for him [at Jorge Newbery Airport in Buenos Aires, when the Pope arrived], up until that point everything seemed like conventional protocol. But when I started watching him come down the aircraft steps, it was a very powerful emotion," he admitted.

Unity and division

Speaking about the private meeting he held with the pontiff at the Casa Rosada presidential palace, Milei said: "The truth is that we discussed issues relating to the moral foundations of politics. We basically spoke about the role of the Holy Scriptures in the decision-making process, something I have been working on. We also discussed natural law." Milei, for his part, said his government was working to avoid "punishing the Argentines of tomorrow in order to benefit the Argentines of today."

Leo also urged Milei to maintain Latin American unity, a reference to turmoil with Brazil. "South America has, at difficult moments in its history, found ways to negotiate and reach understanding in order to overcome serious tensions," Leo said Sunday evening alongside Milei. "Argentina is called to preserve this willingness to engage in dialogue and help it continue to bear fruit." Milei has refused to acknowledge President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva's upset victory last month in Brazil's elections and helped his right-wing rival Flávio Bolsonaro flee to the US through Argentina.

The Pope called for "coordinated action among states" to confront the threats of organised crime, corruption, and arms and drug-trafficking shaking the region. "That strength also depends on the personal integrity of those entrusted with the responsibility of governing, because corruption erodes citizens' trust in their institutions," he added. About 39 percent of Argentines approve of Milei's government, down from 43 percent at the start of the year, according to LatAm Pulse, a survey conducted in September by AtlasIntel for Bloomberg News.

Leo will visit a home for disabled people and a prison and celebrate three open-air masses while in Argentina. The Church has said it expects around seven million faithful to attend the various events. Leo, who isn't visiting Brazil on this trip, will remain in Argentina until Wednesday when he departs for Peru, the longest and most personal leg of his journey.

Frequently asked questions

What did Pope Leo say about Milei's austerity measures?

Pope Leo said the economy must be at the service of the people, not the reverse, and stressed concern for the poor, pensioners, and those affected by illness, dependency, and disability.

How did Milei respond to the Pope's critique?

Milei said he was not against dialogue but accused the opposition of intellectual dishonesty, citing 40 bills that sought to undermine macroeconomic stability. He also said he was 'moved' by the visit.

When does Pope Leo leave Argentina?

Pope Leo will remain in Argentina until Wednesday, when he departs for Peru, the longest and most personal leg of his journey.

More from this edition