Skip to main content

Kaer NewsPolitics

Trump administration proposes selling public lands to shrink federal estate

The Interior Department's new strategic plan proposes selling federal lands to states, tribes and local governments, drawing bipartisan congressional opposition.

4 min read
Trump administration proposes selling public lands to shrink federal estatePhoto: The Week

Key points

The Trump administration's Interior Department plans to sell federal lands to reduce the federal estate, facing bipartisan congressional opposition.

The Trump administration's Interior Department has proposed selling federal lands to states, tribes and local governments as part of a new strategic plan to 'decrease the size of the federal estate,' according to a plan presented by the agency. The proposal, reported on 12 November, marks a break with 50 years of precedent that largely limited land sales.

Interior officials said the sales would allow the government to focus resources on 'nationally significant lands,' which were not defined. They offered no details on what parcels could be sold, nor the scope or location of potential sales. The department oversees more than 1.9 million square kilometres of land, an area greater than Texas and California combined, along with vast underground mineral reserves.

Plan details and scope

The five-year strategic plan, covering 2026 to 2030, also calls for land transfers and exchanges to support greater energy production, a centrepiece of the administration's pro-fossil fuel policies. It reflects the view of most public lands as assets to be used rather than set aside for preservation. The plan was last updated four years ago under former President Joe Biden.

The proposal drew quick pushback from lawmakers, including Trump's former Interior secretary, Republican Rep. Ryan Zinke. Zinke's office said in a statement that he 'remains firmly opposed to the sale or transfer of public lands' and would vote against any legislation on the issue before he leaves Congress after this term. The opposition shows the plan faces strong headwinds even before Democrats assume the majority in January.

Democratic New Mexico Sen. Martin Heinrich, poised to take control of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, said federal lands 'belong to the American people, not private interests looking to cash in.' California Democratic Rep. Jared Huffman, the top Democrat on the House Natural Resources Committee, said Democrats would resist the move. 'Americans love their public lands and sent a clear message last week: the Trump administration's schemes to auction off our treasured resources and silence opposition must stop now. Democrats in Congress are going to deliver,' Huffman said.

Congressional opposition

The plan also declared that Interior will no longer use the Land and Water Conservation Fund to expand the federal government's real estate footprint. The congressionally mandated fund receives $900 million annually, a portion of which is required for land acquisition, but Interior said it will instead use the money to increase access on privately owned lands.

Federal law puts significant constraints on public land sales, said Mark Squillace, a professor of natural resources law at University of Colorado Law School. Land cannot be sold if it is under protected status, and before a sale can occur, it must be deemed appropriate under certain criteria, including land that is uneconomic to manage or where a sale would 'serve important public objectives, including but not limited to, expansion of communities and economic development.'

The Bureau of Land Management, which oversees about 40% of all federal lands, has the greatest freedom to pursue land sales compared to other arms of the federal government, but even that power is quite limited. Interior officials said a portion of any land sale proceeds would be returned to the buyer for conservation purposes elsewhere. It's uncertain if Interior Secretary Doug Burgum can achieve the administration's goals without cooperation from Congress.

Legal and historical limits

Some Western lawmakers last year sought to sell vast tracts of land in Utah and Nevada, saying that could generate revenue and ease growth pressures in booming cities. Utah Republican Sen. Mike Lee suggested selling more than 2 million acres (8,000 square kilometres) to states or other entities. Those efforts failed amid bipartisan opposition.

Tracy Stone-Manning, who served as director of the Bureau of Land Management during the Biden administration and now leads the Wilderness Society, called the new policy 'an unprecedented step that defies history.' The first Trump administration's strategic plan for the Interior Department made no mention of land sales, swaps or disposal. The plan sets out a road map for the Interior Department's priorities and actions between 2026 and 2030, but future administrations would not be bound by it.

The Interior Department did not respond to request for comment. The Associated Press sent emails to Interior officials Wednesday requesting comment and further details. The department regulates mining, drilling, grazing, recreation and other activities that many state and local officials want greater control over. Interior includes the Bureau of Land Management, National Park Service, Fish and Wildlife Service and Bureau of Indian Affairs.

Burgum and Housing and Urban Development Secretary Scott Turner last year proposed using 'underutilised' federal land for affordable housing. Turner said some 7 million homes were needed. Officials under Biden also sought to use public lands for affordable housing, although on a smaller scale. The plan's future remains uncertain as Congress returns and Democrats prepare to take the majority in January.

Frequently asked questions

What does the Interior Department's plan propose?

The plan proposes selling federal lands to states, tribes and local governments to decrease the size of the federal estate, focusing resources on 'nationally significant lands.' It also stops using the Land and Water Conservation Fund for land acquisition.

Who opposes the land sales?

Republican Rep. Ryan Zinke, a former Interior secretary, and Democrats like Sen. Martin Heinrich and Rep. Jared Huffman oppose the sales. Zinke said he would vote against any legislation, while Heinrich and Huffman pledged to fight the plan.

What legal limits exist on federal land sales?

Federal law restricts sales: land under protected status cannot be sold, and sales must meet criteria like being uneconomic to manage or serving important public objectives such as community expansion or economic development.

More from this edition