France's PM asked operators to block four apps before protests
Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu asked French telecom operators to be ready to block TikTok, Instagram, Snapchat and X before the 24 October protests, a letter revealed by Blast shows.
Photo: POLITICOKey points
France's government asked telecom operators to prepare to block TikTok, Instagram, Snapchat and X before the 24 October protests, but the plan was not carried out.
France's government explored blocking social networks and mobile internet during the protests on Saturday 24 October, contacting telecom operators in the week leading up to Oct. 24, according to a report. Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu directly asked operators to be ready to block TikTok, Instagram, Snapchat and X, in a letter revealed by the French digital outlet Blast.
The plan never took effect, and far fewer incidents were recorded on Oct. 24 than on 17 October, when scenes of violence prompted the government's concern. The interior ministry said Sunday that authorities arrested more than 1,300 people during nationwide demonstrations Saturday, while 53 security personnel were injured. The government feared the violence of 17 October could repeat or escalate the following weekend.
What the letter asked operators to do
The push culminated in Lecornu's letter asking French telecom operators to be ready to block access to TikTok, Instagram, Snapchat and X. Officials from Lecornu's office, the technology ministry and the interior ministry did not deny the move or the letter's existence when contacted. One government official from the Prime Minister's office and one telecom employee described the contacts with operators.
An employee of a telecommunications provider, granted anonymity to speak freely, said the government wanted above all to block the communication channels that allow gangs to meet up and organize. The interior ministry contacted operators in the week leading up to Oct. 24 to explore cutting access to social networks or mobile internet in specific areas to prevent rioters from coordinating.
Blocking access to social networks in a targeted area, such as a specific neighborhood, is not technically possible, according to the government official and telecom employee. Cutting mobile internet instead would cause major disruptions to other key services, including mobile payments, security-surveillance devices and emergency communications. The intervention would also have prevented peaceful protesters from communicating, not only those the government sought to stop.
Why a targeted block was impossible
The government also considered a less radical solution that would disable geolocation display features, to prevent gatherings of people who don't know each other, according to the official from the prime minister's office. This option would have addressed coordination without cutting off mobile internet entirely, avoiding the disruption to payments, surveillance and emergency communications that a full shutdown would cause.
The Interior Ministry said Sunday that authorities arrested more than 1,300 people during nationwide demonstrations Saturday, while 53 security personnel were injured. The ministry said 410,000 people took part in Saturday's demonstrations across France, including 110,000 in Paris. Trade unions estimated nationwide turnout at nearly 800,000, with 250,000 protesters in the capital. The ministry also said 24 businesses were looted, compared with 1,522 a week earlier, a decline of more than 98%.
Other limitations on social media access are being discussed in parliament as part of the debate on the so-called "who breaks pays" bill, which would hold people who knowingly took part in a riot financially responsible, whether or not they committed property damage themselves. The same bill would require platforms to remove within 24 hours content that incites physical or sexual assault, theft, destruction, or property damage when such content is likely to cause a serious disturbance to public order.
What parliament is now debating
The bill would also require platforms to remove within one hour content that encourages insurrection. Other lawmakers are proposing measures ranging from tracking troublemakers via algorithmic video surveillance to penalizing online marketplaces that fail to prevent the sale of stolen goods. These proposals extend the debate beyond the shutdown idea, which was never implemented during the October 24 protests, where significantly fewer acts of violence were recorded than the previous weekend.
Frequently asked questions
What did France's government ask telecom operators to do before the protests?
Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu directly asked French telecom operators to be ready to block access to TikTok, Instagram, Snapchat and X, in a letter revealed by the French digital outlet Blast. Officials from Lecornu's office, the technology ministry and the interior ministry did not deny the letter's existence.
Why was blocking social media in specific areas not carried out?
Blocking access to social networks in a targeted area, such as a specific neighborhood, is not technically possible. Cutting mobile internet instead would cause major disruptions to mobile payments, security-surveillance devices and emergency communications, and would also prevent peaceful protesters from communicating.
How many people were arrested during the protests on Saturday?
The Interior Ministry said Sunday that authorities arrested more than 1,300 people during nationwide demonstrations Saturday, while 53 security personnel were injured. The ministry said 410,000 people took part in the demonstrations, including 110,000 in Paris.


