Skip to main content

Kaer NewsPolitics

New Jersey cheese importer sues Trump over 50% Canada tariffs

Gellert Global Group filed suit on Tuesday in the US Court of International Trade over 50% tariffs on Canadian goods, saying it paid more than $520,000 in duties between 16 September and 11 October.

4 min read
New Jersey cheese importer sues Trump over 50% Canada tariffsPhoto: Al Jazeera

Key points

A New Jersey cheese importer sued Donald Trump over 50% tariffs on Canadian goods, arguing he lacked authority to impose them without Congress.

A New Jersey food importer that buys Canadian cheese sued President Donald Trump on Tuesday over his 50 percent tariffs on Canadian goods, arguing he lacks the legal authority to impose sweeping tariffs without congressional approval. Gellert Global Group filed the lawsuit in the US Court of International Trade in New York, and between 16 September and 11 October it paid more than $520,000 in duties, according to the complaint.

The case tests whether a Depression-era statute that no president had used before Trump can carry tariffs of up to 50 percent on a wide range of Canadian products, including dairy, furniture, clothing and wine. The tariffs are already raising costs for importers and disrupting supplier relationships on both sides of the border, and the outcome will decide whether importers can recover duties they have already paid with interest.

What the lawsuit argues

The lawsuit targets Section 338 of the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930, which lets the president impose tariffs of up to 50 percent on imports from countries found to discriminate against American businesses. Trump first imposed the 50 percent tariffs over the summer, accusing Canada of discriminating against American-made cars, alcohol and dairy products, and expanded the measures in September after Canada retaliated with its own tariffs on US goods.

The Liberty Justice Center argues that Congress replaced Section 338 with newer laws, beginning with the Reciprocal Trade Agreements Act of 1934 and culminating in Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974, which requires an investigation, public comment and other safeguards. Jeffrey Schwab, the centre's senior counsel and director of litigation, said the administration cannot skip those protections by reaching for a 1930 statute.

Gellert Global Group estimates the tariffs will cost it $40 million a year on cheese imports alone. The company, a $1.7 billion business, imported $71 million worth of Canadian cheese last year, including goat's milk cheese, brie, mascarpone and camembert. One supplier buys milk from dairy farmers in upstate New York, makes brie in Canada and ships the finished cheese back to the United States.

How much the duties add up to

The lawsuit also questions why Canadian cheese is taxed over disputes involving alcohol and cars, noting that two of the Canadian policies cited arose in response to the president's own tariffs while the third involves Canadian dairy policy governed by the US-Mexico-Canada Agreement. Sara Albrecht, chairman and chief executive of the Liberty Justice Center, said no president should pull a dormant statute off the shelf.

Gellert is asking the court to declare the tariffs illegal, stop their collection and order refunds with interest for affected importers, and the lawsuit asks the court to certify a class of importers numbering in the hundreds, if not the thousands. Thomas Gellert, the company's co-chief executive officer, said the tariffs disrupt relationships built over generations overnight.

What other tariff cases have done

The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Trade negotiations between President Trump and Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney broke down, with Carney blaming last-minute changes in the US proposed terms that he called unfair and uneconomic and said called into question the reliability of any deal.

This lawsuit marks the fourth major legal challenge to Trump's tariffs. In February, the US Supreme Court struck down most tariffs imposed in 2025 under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, and the government has been refunding those payments with interest. In May, the Court of International Trade ruled against tariffs imposed under Section 122 of the 1974 Trade Act.

A separate challenge to tariffs imposed under Section 301 over alleged forced labour in international trade remains pending before the Court of International Trade, which is also weighing other cases. The Liberty Justice Center won its February Supreme Court case against the administration and is now asking the trade court to block the 50 percent Canadian tariffs with a preliminary injunction.

Frequently asked questions

Who is suing Trump over the Canadian tariffs?

Gellert Global Group, a New Jersey company that imports Canadian cheese, filed the lawsuit on Tuesday in the US Court of International Trade in New York. The Liberty Justice Center filed the suit on the company's behalf.

How much has the importer paid in tariff duties?

Between 16 September and 11 October, Gellert Global Group paid more than $520,000 in duties, according to the complaint. The company estimates the tariffs will cost it $40 million a year on cheese imports.

What law does the lawsuit challenge?

The lawsuit challenges Section 338 of the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act of 1930, which allows tariffs of up to 50 percent on countries found to discriminate against American businesses. No president had used it before Trump invoked it this year.

More from this edition