Judge strikes DOJ obstruction charge against two ex-FBI officials in Washington
Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui dismissed an unsigned obstruction complaint against former FBI officials Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides at a Washington hearing on 27 October, ruling the Justice Department skipped the required sign-off.
Photo: NBC NewsKey points
A federal judge struck an unsigned obstruction charge against former FBI officials Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides after prosecutors filed it without a judge's sign-off.
Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui dismissed a new obstruction charge against former FBI officials Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides at a hearing in Washington on 27 October, ruling that the Justice Department filed an unsigned complaint without a judge's sign-off. The pair already face charges of making false statements to Congress about their knowledge of investigations into Hunter Biden's laptop.
The struck filing matters because it is the first time, according to the judge, that prosecutors in the district filed a criminal complaint without a magistrate judge's approval. Faruqui said he was aware of no previous instance of such a filing. The obstruction charge would have expanded the case beyond the false-statements counts, which carry up to five years in prison if the defendants are convicted.
What the filing changes
Prosecutors filed the superseding complaint overnight, adding an obstruction charge against both defendants. Prosecutor John Borchert of the U.S. attorney's office for Washington, D.C., acknowledged in court that "this has never been done before" but suggested the complaint could be signed during the hearing. Faruqui denied the request and struck it, questioning why the Justice Department had not followed what it had done in "every other case in the history of this district."
Faruqui said he did not doubt that the prosecution acted in good faith but expressed concern that "this system is being misused by people of higher levels." He told prosecutors their conduct bolstered the defence claim that "everything here is atypical and bizarre and that is because this is not an appropriate case." He also said, "Everything is a sideshow on top of a sideshow" in this case, and asked why prosecutors would "upend the entire history of how we charge cases."
U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro, before the judge struck the filing, told reporters the decision was Faruqui's to make. "It's up to Judge Faruqui as to whether or not he wants to sign that," Pirro said, noting the government had a prior signed complaint and the ability to add a charge. Prosecutors denied doing anything improper and argued they were not legally required to seek a judge's sign-off on the new complaint.
Where the numbers came from
FBI Special Agent Bryan Witt testified that the investigation began in July, the day after President Donald Trump gave a primetime speech directing the FBI and other agencies to examine whether the U.S. intelligence community suppressed information about foreign meddling in the 2020 election. FBI Director Kash Patel sent a letter directing the Kansas City, Missouri, field office to look into certain people, including Floris. Witt called the assignment a "huge distraction" from a public corruption case he was working on.
Witt told the court he had concerns the case would be viewed as political. He said the investigation was "prioritized" and that they were "told to work it aggressively," with check-ins from high-level officials including Patel and an FBI deputy director. Asked whether Patel pressed him, Witt said he did not. He agreed the assignment was "unusual" but said he was instructed to investigate potential crimes, not told a crime had occurred.
Floris and Benavides were supervisors on the FBI's foreign influence task force before the 2020 election and testified to the House Judiciary Committee in 2023. Floris said she had no knowledge of the laptop; Benavides said he first learned of it on "Wikipedia." Witt said Benavides' account contradicted chat logs and direct messages but acknowledged he had no direct evidence the statement was intentionally false.
What happens next
Justice Department officials have argued the former officials should be held accountable for misleading a congressional investigation, and prosecutors deny political motivation. Faruqui made no ruling on the original false-statements charges after a full day of testimony. The hearing in the case was scheduled to continue on Wednesday, with the judge still to decide whether the government showed probable cause on the original charges of making false statements to Congress.
Frequently asked questions
Why did the judge strike the new charge?
Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui dismissed a superseding complaint adding an obstruction charge because it was filed overnight without a judge's signature. Prosecutor John Borchert acknowledged in court that "this has never been done before." Faruqui said prosecutors had not followed what they had done in every other case in the district.
What are Nikki Floris and Bradley Benavides charged with?
Both former FBI officials are charged with making false statements to the House Judiciary Committee in 2023 about their knowledge of investigations into Hunter Biden's laptop. They face up to five years in prison if convicted. An added obstruction charge was struck by the judge.
Why did an FBI agent say the case looked political?
FBI Special Agent Bryan Witt testified the probe began in July, the day after President Trump's primetime speech directing an examination of foreign meddling in the 2020 election. FBI Director Kash Patel then directed the Kansas City field office to investigate. Witt said he feared it would be viewed as political.


