Skip to main content

Kaer NewsPolitics

Obama accuses Trump of targeting Omar over her political criticism

Former president Barack Obama accused the Trump administration on 18 October of trying to deport Congresswoman Ilhan Omar because she criticised President Donald Trump, after federal agents searched her Washington home on 12 October.

4 min read
Obama accuses Trump of targeting Omar over her political criticismPhoto: Punch Newspapers

Key points

Barack Obama accused the Trump administration of trying to deport Congresswoman Ilhan Omar as punishment for criticising President Donald Trump.

Former president Barack Obama accused the Trump administration on 18 October of trying to deport Congresswoman Ilhan Omar because she criticised President Donald Trump, calling the effort an attack on American democracy. Obama posted on X that the government was selectively targeting the Minnesota Democrat. Federal agents had searched Omar's Washington home on 12 October under a judicially authorised warrant, part of what the Justice Department described as an ongoing federal criminal investigation into her immigration paperwork.

Obama's intervention matters because it elevates a sitting president's criticism of a successor's use of federal law enforcement against an elected rival, days before midterm elections on 3 November in which Omar is standing for re-election in Minnesota's 5th Congressional District. The case turns on a narrow legal question about Omar's age when her father became a naturalised citizen — a point on which Obama's public account and the governing law before February 2001 do not fully align.

What Obama's post alleged

Obama wrote that it is a basic principle of American democracy that the government cannot selectively target individuals because of their political beliefs or what they say. He said Omar arrived in the United States with her father at 12, and five years later, when her father became a naturalised citizen, she became one too because she was 17. An 18-year-old would have had to apply separately, he noted.

Obama alleged the administration was trying to deport Omar based on an unsubstantiated theory that she was actually 18 when her father naturalised and therefore is not a citizen. He said federal agents raided her home, confiscated personal records and seized her phone, trying to uncover what he called a nonexistent smoking gun from 20 years ago. The post had more than six million views at the time of writing.

The citizenship question is narrower than Obama's account suggests. Investigators are examining whether Omar or her late father provided false information on immigration documents, according to three people familiar with the matter who spoke to the Washington Post. One said the Department of Homeland Security had declined similar allegations years earlier. The legal requirements before February 2001 involved conditions beyond age alone, so Obama's explanation is not a complete account of the governing law. No criminal charges have been announced.

The citizenship question at issue

Omar, a naturalised citizen from Somalia, was a child when her father filled out the paperwork. Her father, Nur Omar Mohamed, died in June 2020. Omar has said she became a US citizen in 2000. Her office said she had done nothing wrong and called the search an outrageous abuse of power. Her attorneys said the search was neither justified nor lawful and accused the Justice Department of potentially influencing an election in violation of longstanding internal policy.

Border czar Tom Homan told a Fox News host on 17 October that denaturalising and then deporting Omar was possible, answering 'Of course' and saying that if someone lies during naturalisation there is a process to denaturalise them. Trump told reporters he had nothing to do with the search and said the matter was up to the Justice Department, adding that he had always found Omar to be totally crooked personally. House Democratic Caucus chair Pete Aguilar called the search deeply disturbing.

Officials respond to the search

Obama compared the case to federal actions involving the New York attorney general, a former head of the Federal Bureau of Investigation and members of the Federal Reserve, saying those prosecutions stalled or were dismissed for having no basis in law. He said any effort to revoke citizenship would require court proceedings, and warned that Omar could face mounting legal bills and distraction from representing Minnesota. As of April, the Justice Department had identified nearly 400 foreign-born citizens it sought to investigate for denaturalisation.

Obama warned that if this becomes the new normal, there is no reason to believe it will stop with Omar, or that future presidents in either party will not do the same. The investigation, launched weeks before the midterms, continues: the government has seized Omar's phone and issued more than a dozen subpoenas, including to her relatives, and Omar is on the ballot on 3 November.

Frequently asked questions

Why does Barack Obama say Ilhan Omar is being targeted?

Obama wrote on X on 18 October that the Trump administration is trying to deport Omar because she has been one of its fiercest critics, calling the effort a selective targeting based on political beliefs rather than evidence.

What is the investigation into Ilhan Omar about?

Federal agents searched her Washington home on 12 October under a warrant, part of a criminal investigation into whether she or her late father provided false information on immigration documents. No charges have been announced.

When are the midterm elections and is Omar running?

Midterm elections are on 3 November, and Omar is seeking another term representing Minnesota's 5th Congressional District, which includes Minneapolis.

More from this edition