Skip to main content

Kaer NewsPolitics

Polish court chief suspended as judges clash over authority

A senior judge suspended Poland's Constitutional Tribunal president on 30 October amid security concerns and political accusations.

3 min read
Polish court chief suspended as judges clash over authorityPhoto: POLITICO

Key points

A senior judge suspended Poland's Constitutional Tribunal president and deputy on 30 October amid security concerns.

Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal entered a state of turmoil on 30 October after a senior judge ordered the suspension of its president and deputy. Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska announced that Bogdan Święczkowski and Bartłomiej Sochański would be suspended for one month. She stated that she was taking charge of the institution during this period. The move triggered immediate condemnation from the suspended officials who described the action as a coup.

The suspension came after Korwin-Piotrowska reported potential threats to the safety of judges and staff at the court. She requested police assistance to secure the building in Warsaw. Officials from the tribunal later claimed their website had suffered an illegal takeover. The court issued a statement warning that those involved were committing the crime of coup d’état.

How the suspension unfolded

Prime Minister Donald Tusk expressed full support for the move on the social media platform X. He argued that restoring the rule of law is a duty for his government. Tusk noted that the process is difficult and sometimes painful following years of PiS led lawlessness. He insisted there is no other way to address the situation.

Outside the tribunal building protesters gathered to show support for the suspended president. Police said objects had been thrown at officers during the demonstration. Authorities detained three people after some individuals climbed over the court fence. The police deployed to maintain security but did not enter the building itself. Police surrounded the headquarters of the Constitutional Tribunal in substantial numbers on Friday night. Law enforcement officers had not physically entered the building despite the tensions. The deployment was requested by Korwin-Piotrowska to address risks to personnel safety. This police presence added to the visual intensity of the political standoff in the capital.

Police respond to threats

President Karol Nawrocki interrupted an official trip to Senegal to return to Poland. He stated that the president must be in the country during such a moment. Nawrocki is a political ally of the Law and Justice party which opposed Tusk. He faced off against Tusk in the recent presidential election.

PiS leader Jarosław Kaczyński joined the protest and accused Tusk of turning Poland into a police state. Kaczyński claimed the government was using state apparatuses to target the court. Former Prime Minister Beata Szydło condemned the security operation as shocking scenes. European Parliament members associated with Nawrocki also characterised the developments as a coup.

Political reactions clash

Justice Minister Waldemar Żurek blamed the turmoil on Święczkowski for turning the institution into a private fiefdom. Żurek said he submitted five requests to lift the immunity of Święczkowski and his deputy. He claimed these requests were backed by fifty volumes of case files. The minister defended Korwin-Piotrowska’s move as a decision by a legally appointed judge.

The crisis stems from a long running dispute over the membership of the Constitutional Tribunal. Nawrocki refused to swear in five judges elected by Tusk’s parliamentary majority earlier this year. These judges took their oaths in parliament but Święczkowski barred them from hearing cases. Previous attempts to reverse judicial reforms have been blocked by PiS aligned presidents.

Longstanding court dispute

PiS has accused the former government of politicising the courts by appointing friendly judges. The tribunal helped impose a near-total abortion ban under PiS rule. It also challenged the supremacy of EU law. The European Union top court ruled last December that the tribunal failed to meet judicial independence standards.

Frequently asked questions

Why was the president of the Constitutional Tribunal suspended?

Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska suspended him for one month after reporting potential threats to judge safety and requesting police assistance.

What actions did Prime Minister Donald Tusk take regarding the crisis?

Tusk backed the suspension on social media stating that restoring the rule of law is his duty after years of PiS led lawlessness.

How did President Karol Nawrocki respond to the events?

Nawrocki cut short an official trip to Senegal to return to Poland where he condemned the move as part of a police state strategy.

More from this edition