Skip to main content

Kaer NewsPolitics

Trump demands Peltola leave Alaska ballot over second Dan Sullivan

On 28 October, President Trump called for Democrat Mary Peltola to be removed from the Alaska Senate ballot and criminally prosecuted, citing a New York Times report that her campaign recruited a candidate sharing Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan's name.

4 min read
Trump demands Peltola leave Alaska ballot over second Dan SullivanPhoto: PUNCH

Key points

On 28 October, President Trump demanded Alaska Democratic Senate candidate Mary Peltola be removed from the ballot and criminally prosecuted, citing a New York Times report that her campaign recruited a candidate sharing Republican incumben

President Trump demanded on 28 October that Alaska Democratic Senate candidate Mary Peltola be removed from next week's ballot and criminally prosecuted, following a New York Times investigation into the recruitment of a candidate sharing the name of Republican incumbent Senator Dan Sullivan. Trump made the demand on his Truth Social platform and to reporters at Joint Base Andrews, saying, "Mary Peltola should resign from the race. I think she should be prosecuted criminally for what she did."

The demand escalates a fight over ballot access days before the election, because it targets a sitting Democratic candidate and a rival whose name matches the Republican incumbent. The Times investigation did not establish criminal wrongdoing or substantiate Trump's allegation of perjury.

What Trump demanded

Trump wrote that "It has just been determined that the Democrats in Alaska illegally searched for, and recruited, a man named Dan Sullivan," and accused Democrats of perjury for allegedly making false statements under oath in federal court. He demanded the incumbent run without Peltola or the "FAKE Dan Sullivan" on the ballot, and in another post wrote that Peltola should not be allowed to run, calling it "ELECTION FRAUD."

Vice President JD Vance echoed Trump, saying, "Even the New York Times admits that Mary Peltola is a total crook who tried to rig the Alaska senate race in her favor." Trump told reporters at Joint Base Andrews that allies who recruited Daniel J. Sullivan should also face criminal charges, adding, "To me, that's voter fraud at the highest level."

Senior aides and lawyers for Peltola, along with officials at the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, were involved in recruiting spoiler candidates, including another Dan Sullivan, to draw votes from Republican Senator Dan Sullivan. The newspaper cited interviews, dozens of text messages, and documents prepared for a potential lawsuit against the campaign. Among those recruited was Daniel J. Sullivan, a retired teacher from a remote Alaskan fishing community, who has said he entered the race of his own volition.

What the Times investigation found

The Times identified Democratic operative Jerid Kurtz as a central figure, reporting he travelled around Alaska under an assumed name to court potential candidates. Kurtz also urged a Democrat to quit after the August primary, opening a place on the four-candidate ranked-choice ballot for Republican Gerald Heikes, another recruit. Heikes told the paper he was recruited by a Midwesterner he did not think resembled a photo of Kurtz. Kurtz did not respond to the Times's requests for comment.

Peltola's former campaign manager Elisa Rios said the candidate was "definitely aware" of the project but not directly involved, and that Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee aides had introduced Kurtz to the campaign. Peltola's campaign and the committee have denied recruiting any candidates.

Trump earlier ordered the Justice Department to sue Alaska over the second Sullivan's presence on the ballot. The lawsuit seeks to delay certification if Peltola narrowly defeats the incumbent and votes for his namesake could have changed the outcome. Alaska has asked a federal judge to dismiss the suit, arguing it has no legal basis. In June, Alaska's Supreme Court upheld retired teacher Daniel J. Sullivan's right to run, rejecting Republican efforts to remove him.

Where the legal fight stands

Both Sullivans appear on next week's ballot alongside Peltola, under Alaska's system in which four candidates advance from the primary to the general election. Recruiting candidates to split an opponent's vote, a practice known as ballot stacking, is generally legal and has been used by both parties in Alaska. Its investigation did not establish criminal wrongdoing or substantiate Trump's allegation of perjury.

Trump's demand for Peltola's removal and prosecution, and his earlier Justice Department lawsuit against Alaska, set up a legal contest over ballot certification. The state has asked a federal judge to dismiss the federal suit, arguing it has no legal basis, while Alaska's Supreme Court has already ruled in June that the second Sullivan can run. The candidates appear on the ballot in next week's election.

Frequently asked questions

Why does Trump want Mary Peltola removed from the Alaska ballot?

On 28 October, Trump demanded Peltola leave the ballot and be prosecuted, citing a New York Times report that her campaign recruited a second Dan Sullivan to draw votes from Republican Senator Dan Sullivan. He called it "ELECTION FRAUD" and alleged perjury.

Did the New York Times report find criminal wrongdoing?

No. The Times noted that recruiting candidates to split an opponent's vote, known as ballot stacking, is generally legal and has been used by both parties in Alaska. Its investigation did not establish criminal wrongdoing or substantiate Trump's perjury allegation.

Can both Dan Sullivans remain on the Alaska ballot?

Yes, for now. Alaska's Supreme Court in June upheld retired teacher Daniel J. Sullivan's right to run, rejecting Republican efforts to remove him. Under Alaska's system, four candidates advance from the primary, and both Sullivans appear with Peltola.

More from this edition