German parliament expands spy agency powers with 309 votes
Germany's parliament approved on 13 November a bill giving intelligence agencies powers to hack foreign systems and recruit informants aged 16, with 309 votes in favour.
Photo: News.azKey points
Germany's parliament approved a bill on 13 November expanding intelligence agency powers, including hacking foreign systems and recruiting informants as young as 16.
Germany's parliament approved on 13 November a bill significantly expanding the powers of the country's intelligence agencies, including authority to conduct covert operations abroad. The bill passed with 309 votes in favour, 190 against and 71 abstentions. Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt described the changes as "the reform of the century," saying Germany needed to strengthen its democracy against threats from both inside and outside the country.
The reform expands the powers of the Federal Intelligence Service (BND), which handles foreign intelligence, and the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution (BfV), responsible for domestic intelligence. The law aims to counter espionage, terrorism, and sabotage. Under certain conditions, the BfV will be allowed to go beyond surveillance and information gathering, including covertly entering private homes and intervening in situations involving explosives or weapons.
New operational powers
The BND will also receive new operational powers, including the authority to disable servers used by state-sponsored hacker groups abroad. This includes the ability to hack foreign IT systems and recruit informants as young as 16. A panel of former judges will assess the legality of specific measures before they are carried out, providing a judicial check on the new powers.
The government says the overhaul is necessary to address growing threats from foreign intelligence services, particularly those of Russia and China, and to reduce Germany's reliance on intelligence provided by its allies. The context includes Russia escalating its hybrid attacks on the West, with Moscow making Europe's life 'hell' for supporting Ukraine. The reform is part of a broader response to these threats.
However, opposition politicians and legal organisations have raised concerns that the changes could undermine civil liberties and weaken the traditional separation between intelligence agencies and law enforcement. The separation is rooted in Germany's postwar political system and its experience under Nazi rule, when the Gestapo combined surveillance and policing powers to persecute political opponents and targeted groups.
Concerns over civil liberties
The German Bar Association warned that allowing intelligence agencies to intervene directly could "jeopardize the constitutionally mandated separation between intelligence services and the police." It also criticised what it described as weaker safeguards for confidential communications between lawyers and their clients. Green Party lawmaker Konstantin von Notz warned that the reform could allow intelligence officers to take action against citizens without the transparency and legal scrutiny required of police.
The bill's passage marks a significant shift in Germany's approach to security, moving from a model where intelligence agencies primarily gather information to one where they can take direct action. The new powers for the BND to disable servers abroad target state-sponsored hacker groups, a response to increasing cyber threats. The BfV's ability to covertly enter homes is limited to situations involving explosives or weapons, and arrests and overt searches remain the responsibility of the police.
The reform has been debated amid rising concerns about foreign interference and sabotage. Germany has previously blamed Russia for a Leipzig plane sabotage attempt, expelled diplomats, and restricted visas. The new law is part of a broader effort to strengthen national security, but critics argue it risks eroding fundamental rights. The panel of former judges is intended to mitigate these risks by reviewing specific measures.
The next step is the implementation of the law, with intelligence agencies expected to adapt their operations to the new powers. The government has not announced a specific date for when the provisions will take effect, but the reform is now in place. The debate over the balance between security and civil liberties is likely to continue as the agencies begin using their expanded authority.
The vote on 13 November was a clear majority, but the 190 against and 71 abstentions show significant opposition. The concerns raised by legal organisations and opposition lawmakers may lead to legal challenges. The reform's impact on Germany's intelligence operations and its relations with allies will be watched closely, especially given the stated goal of reducing reliance on allied intelligence.
Frequently asked questions
What did the German parliament approve on 13 November?
The parliament approved a bill expanding intelligence agency powers, including covert operations abroad, hacking foreign IT systems, and recruiting informants as young as 16. The vote was 309 in favour, 190 against, and 71 abstentions.
Why did Germany expand its intelligence agency powers?
The government says the reform is necessary to counter espionage, terrorism, and sabotage, particularly from Russia and China, and to reduce reliance on allied intelligence. Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt called it 'the reform of the century.'
What concerns have been raised about the reform?
Opposition politicians and legal organisations, including the German Bar Association, worry it could undermine civil liberties and weaken the separation between intelligence agencies and police. Green Party lawmaker Konstantin von Notz warned of actions without transparency.


